More Politics & Law Questions

Could my roommate sue me over his "derivative work" on my photos?

I paid a former roommate the cost of ink and photo paper to quickly scan in an old family photograph that I wanted to have fixed up and framed for a relative. He spent less than two minutes on Photoshop doing it, simply adjusting the black levels and adding a slight sepia tone. I was going to have more printed out so I could have a copy framed for another relative, but I had a falling out with this roommate and he is threatening to sue me, citing “derivative work/copyright” as a means to say I can’t photocopy the restored photo, nor can I restore it myself. Would he actually be able to sue me over this? And considering it’s not for profit, and the minimal, generic effort put into restoring it, would he even have grounds to sue me?

Ask your Politics & Law question now...

Become an Expert →

Could my roommate sue me over his "derivative work" on my photos?

Answer #1

Did you have a signed contract? If not, then it’s hearsay - his word against yours. Besides that, it’s your photo.

If you want to play it safe, though, just use your original photo and make your own adjustments to it - he can’t use your photo without consent, even if he did make some edits on it.

Answer #2

No signed contract, he simply got a few $ to make some very minor adjustments.

More Like This

Could this plan work ? - 1 Answers
Rumor Mill: Armstrong Williams reports that the Obama campaign and New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg have devised a plan in ...
Could we sue for this? - 9 Answers
So my mom has been complaining about the fact that our shower runs out of hot water after 2 showers(6 people live here, and i...
Could this plan work? - 3 Answers
Rumor Mill: Armstrong Williams reports that the Obama campaign and New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg have devised a plan in ...
If sombebody falls on the street because the floor is frozen can he sue or not? - 2 Answers
If somebody falls on the street because the floor is frozen and the ambulance take hin can he sue the city or not? Just curio...
Rivals working as a team - 3 Answers
President-elect Obama has picked three of his former rivals for the Democratic nomination, Joe Biden, Hillary Clinton, and Bi...
Israel and Gaza thing could turn into a WWIII??? - 3 Answers
does anyone think that the Israel and Gaza thing could turn into a WWIII???
13 year olds working in politics? - 5 Answers
Is there anywere in ohio a 13 year old can get a job with politics or law
How are people selected to work at Area 51? - 6 Answers
How does that process work? Just curious. Me and my dad were talking about it and didn't know. How are people chosen (and wh...
Does anyone actually care if Canada Prime Minister Stephen Harper photo-shopped his Christmas card? - 2 Answers
Harper is being called out on his 2011 Christmas card which seems photo-shopped with his family from photos of previous years...
What could be the reasons why our country is still a third world co - 5 Answers
What could be the reasons why our country is still a third world country?

Ask an advisor one-on-one!

Could my roommate sue me over his "derivative work" on my photos?

Did you have a signed contract? If not, then it’s hearsay - his word against yours. Besides that, it’s your photo.

Kapuza Lighty PLLC

Law Office of Annie Scott

Top Law Office

VisaOne Canada Inc.

Virender Singh Kadian