Funadvice Logo
Explore Join
More Pets and Animals Questions

My two Dogs fight all the time...

I have a 5 yr old Golden Retriever and a 1 1/2 yr old Brittany Spaniel Lab mix. I love both my dogs. However Hank the Saint/ aka Hank the Gentle Giant (My Golden) is my favorite. Roxy- the Brit/Lab- is a spoiled obnoxious and demanding “pup”. However she is a good Guard dog so that makes me happy. Hank loved the tiny pup at first, and tolerated a lot from her- like her stealing his food…etc. He’d even back off if she snapped at him! Hank has finally had enough of her and is finally standing up for himself. I love it. In the past I have broken up the fights when Roxy was beating up on Hank. But now I let them fight it out- if I see that Hank is winning. Mostly these “fights” consist of loud growling and some movement but neither Dog ever gets injured that I can see. There is never blood. Thes fights are usually caused over a bone or food. When Roxy was being bossy our lives were chaos. Now that Hank is in charge We are back in harmony. Roxy knows her place and things are calmer. Is it bad that I let these fights continue? (These fights happen about twice a week- sometimes more) I really want Hank to be the Alpha Dog. Let me know your opinion.

Become an Expert →
Answer #1

I beleive that the problem is that one of your dog is trying to be the leader in your family. and beleive me if that dog beleive she is the leader of the other dog then she thinks she is your leader also. the only way to change things around is to show your dog that YOU are the leader. your first mistake was to let you baby dog bug the older one. you do not need to hit your dog or to raise the voice. what you need to do is to show that you are strong and seperate the dogs when they are fighting and DO NOT allowed any bad action from any dog they will then realise that you are the leader and that they cant act like the house/property belongs to them. it is yours.

think of it like a bunch of wolves there is only one leader .. this has to be you not one of the dog. he doesnt respect you.

oh I almost forgot… have you ever seen a dog punishing her puppy? she takes him to the ground level and held him there. try it good luck

Answer #2

with a male and female dog, the female will always be the alpha (boss) its just how it is no matter if she is younger etc. I have a girl puppy and a boy dog who is 2 and she isa slowly becoming the boss!!! NEVER LET YOUR DOGS FIGHT IT OUT!!! having a fav dog will only cause problems with your dogs!!! treat them the same, disaplin them the same and play with them the same!!! you are supposed to be the Alpha not the dogs!!! any fights that are playfull are ok but when it gets rought seperate them and disaplin them!!!

one day the fight will be serious and you many loose one of your dogs or have a huge vets bill!!!

Answer #3

Well, what you “want” might not be how the dogs see it. I can only tell you what I’d do in this situation…one…I’d NEVER feed them close together…if they each get bone…put them on opposite sides of the room…if one starts making a move for the other, YOU STOP THE MOVEMENT, by staning up…and a sharp sound…like “Achhh”…

So yes, it is BAD if these fights continue…and YOU should be alpha, and both of them should be beta’s. You’re favoritism (like letting a fight go if Hank is winning…and probably feeding him first…petting him first…etc etc) while the dogs know who is the alpha personality…causes more disharmony than anything the dogs could dream up on their own. Nature provides the alpha personality…NOT the human.

p

More Like This
Advisor

Pets and Animals

Pet Care, Animal Behavior, Veterinary Medicine

Ask an advisor one-on-one!
Advisor

Simply For Dogs

Pets, Dogs, Blogs

Advisor

Dogs Forum

Pet Care, Dog Training, Dog Breeding

Advisor

SitDropStay - Dog Training

Pet Training, Dog Behavior Consulting, Puppy Training

Advisor

Dogdayz Dog Boarding

Dog Boarding, Pet Accommodation, Dog Grooming

Advisor

Wallys World of Dogs

Dog Training, Pet Services, Animal Care