English in a Language Policy

Hey I was wondering, in a place like South Africa where we have 11 official languages, why would English be the main medium of instruction in schools. And yes I know that it would benefit the students for when they want to find employment, seeing as we live in such an English-dominated world; but what about the minority languages? How do we still nourish these minority and indigenous languages in addition to enforcing English as the medium of instruction etc.

Answer #1

You do not need English to be the primary language to be able to be fluent in English and Afrikaans or other languages. When I was young, my dad would force us during holidays to take out at least 3 English books from the library.

You are one of few. I attended an Afrikaans primary school and high school and most of the people in there still can’t speak proper English. In fact most Afrikaans people I know that even study in Afrikaans has poor communication skills when it comes to English. They have a horrible accent and get the language all mixed up. It makes them look very unprofessional and uneducated. Also South-Africans communicate to the rest of the world through English, so that is why I see it as so important.

I agree that Afrikaans should still have their classes in Afrikaans, but they should be forced to have English as a primary language, not necessarily have all their subjects in English. (In other words English Second language, the subject should be removed)

Furthermore I see no reason why all English schools should be forced to even have Afrikaans, whether as second language or not. It’s pointless, because they do not speak it overall.

Answer #2

It is difficult…I attended an Afrikaans preschool, high school and university! You do not need English to be the primary language to be able to be fluent in English and Afrikaans or other languages. When I was young, my dad would force us during holidays to take out at least 3 English books from the library. We had to read them, and at the end of the holiday he would ask us questions about the books. This really helped us with English! But I do not think they should force all Afrikaans schools to go English. Children should have a choice were they want to go and in what language they want to learn.

Answer #3

Considering English is the second most spoken language in the world, it’s no wonder that most of the manuals and instructions are written in English first and then followed by other foreign languages.

I”m not sure about Africa, but imagine every instruction manuals catering for the 11 different languages you have just mentioned above, a person would be carrying a backpack full of booklets.

Answer #4

Here is what we do. We make English the main language and then have the option for all the other languages in schools, and maybe add a language like Hindii etc.

Also we shouldn’t take away the right that Afrikaans schools have to educate their children in Afrikaans, but I do believe that English as a Primary language should be forced into Afrikaans schools (half of the people there can’t even speak proper English)

And then lastly I see no reason why the Indian schools should be having Afrikaans as a second language when they are failing it and will never use it.

Answer #5

because english is a big language.

like you said.. there are 11 languages in one country. in england there is one. + the majority of uk + usa. dont forget these are 2 of the biggest superpowers.

More Like This
Ask an advisor one-on-one!
Advisor

Pakistan English Language Tea...

Education, Non-Profit, Professional Development

Advisor

ICD Institute of English Lang...

Education, Language Learning, Test Preparation

Advisor

Ezylearn Languages Academy

Language Education, Online Courses, Tutoring Services

Advisor

Spoken English Classes | Lear...

Language Training, Education, Communication Skills

Advisor

The Different Languages

Translation Services, Language Learning, Cultural Studies