I tried proactive and so did my sister, she has dry skin and it made her break out terribly and I have very oily skin and it made my skin very dry and made me get more pimples. I would not recommend it, but what works for one person may not work for another. I would give the skin ID a chance , it seems more designed to fit different skin types.
Proactive has a tendency to irritate people with sensative skin, i would go with skin id.
I hated proactive when I tried it so I wouldn't suggest that. Try the skin ID
pro active is HORRIBLE. i used it. it just makes you red.