the 17 year old becuz wen we r that age we need privacy in a room especially with our "friends" if u get wat that means... but ya definatly the 17 year old becuz an eight year old isnt mature enough most of the time to b alone in their room and they r way young so it doesnt matter anyways.... and if u need to make this quick desicion then flip a coin 4 it. and pick heads
17 year old, they need more privacy and space, theyre obviously going through changes unlike an 8 year old.
My little step brother is 8 and he has his own room only because his mom forced him to so my big 17 year old brother and I had to share a room. Un fair right?
well my bro moved out so now I have my own room! :D
I would def say the 17 year old!
They need room to study or just have a little privacy when friends come over w/o having their 8 year old brother or sister constantly interfering. I know the feeling...had one of those(my little brother - 9.5 years apart) :P
I don't like to answer questions like this. There's no background information, and when the answer is pretty obvious from the way it is stated, I always suspect that something else is going on.
Well it depends,if its a girl she needs her own room. If a guythen the 17 year should it. Speaking of which I get my own room in a few weeks YAY! =3
As people have said, the 17 year old just from the question. I had my own room at that age and would have been uncomfortable otherwise.
Definitely the 17 year old. The 8 year old has no need for an entire room to themselves. 17 year old needs the space and privacy.
definitely the 17 year old. a couple of years and theyll be outta there. then the 8 year old can have the room
i'd say a 17 year old would appreciate the privacy more than an 8yr old
The 17 year old is more mature and should deserve a room for herself.
Ooops sorry read question wrong, the 17 yr old shud get thr own room
The 17 yr old needs their own room while the 8 yr old does not. :)
The 17 yeaar old. 8 year olds dont need the privacy or the space.
The 17 year old. Teens need PRIVACY !!
The 17 year old ofcourse
17 year old