Is getting a Saturday school for passing one note in class a good punishment?

Answer #1

nope. the punishment is too severe. a detention would be more fitting

Answer #2

….thats what i said, and the worst of it is thats the only way I can communicate (dont ask why)

Answer #3

That seems extreme to me. We would of gotten a 15 minute after school detention for that.

Answer #4

Depends. Since the real world isnt like an abstract hypothetical situation, I would want to know what the student’s record was in that class. If you’re talking about someone who’s always on time, doesn’t talk during class, and is getting good grades, i’d say a warning should suffice. However, if someone does not have a spotless record, it may be a fitting punishment.

More Like This
Funadvice Logo

© FUNADVICE 2025 · 212bydesign LLC

Answering questions since 2006

[email protected]

Miami, Florida, USA