Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Im confederate does that make me racist?

Asked by wolfgun about 1 year ago, 7 answers.

Im a Northern Confederate I plan to move south and all. Its weird I dont understand why people think the confederacy is all about slavery. Slavery was a political issue of that time and that time only.
This is my definition of a Confederate they...

believe in limited government following the first constition of the United states. I believe the first constition was the best constition for America . I believe in a liberated south with equality and freedom all rights to all citizens. I'm against the KKK or any other group thats racist I believe they dont represent the confederate cause I'm strongly against slavery. I believe we are all human and not seperated into distinct races. Im against segregation of any kind Im for southern unity but being seperate nations united under a federal government. The confederate government was the official first constition of America it has been revised to correct failures of the first.
I recognize slaverys roll in the lead up to the war I believe southerners fought for their nations and to protect their families. I believe slavery was on its way out but was to be delt with responsibly by the Confederate states to be eliminated gradually that would not cause harsh ecnomic turmoil this was better then the unions belief in speedy freeing without taking in account ecnomic impact on both sides agreed on the end of slavery they only differed in how it was to be done. This and other abuses led to session to preserve peace and the safety of southern citizens. T

IQ Answered by religionisgood on Oct 07, 2008, 01:56PM
480 answers

Wrong. The Civil War was not about preserving states' rights or limited government, it was about keeping a good economy going.

The Southern states were to cotton and tobacco what OPEC is to petroleum. Nearly three-fifths of the entire world's supply of cotton was coming from the Southern US at one point. It was bringing an enormous profit to the South, and the margins were as high as they were partly because of slave labor. Obviously, the plantation economy could not survive without that cheap labor. Tensions continued to increase over the issue of slavery as new slave and free states entered the Union. It became clear to the South that their livelihood and economic independence would end if Congress and the presidency were controlled by free states. The South saw the election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860 as a total defeat, and believed there was no way to influence federal policy any longer. Many Southerners had preferred to secede while James Buchanan was president, since he was moderate on the issue and considered weak leadership. Once Lincoln was elected, they figured it was pointless. Secession was motivated by their desire to preserve the slave economy.

You can think what you want to about the Confederacy, but let's not confuse their motives. They did NOT want slavery to end, and that's exactly what the war was about.

2 people thought this was helpful
The Fiance and Me at a Luau Answered by mandyloo on Oct 07, 2008, 12:00PM
7496 answers
Advisor-small

People often assume that confederate means racist. Which is does not in any way. I'm from south louisiana so I know what you talking about. The problem with that is though, that most racist people do use the confederate flag as racist propaganda. So when people see it, they think racist.
I live in a town where the KKK is very active and very well known. They all have confederate flags on their cars, on the houses, etc. So people associate the two around here.

Toadaly Answered by toadaly on Oct 07, 2008, 12:02PM
4232 answers

Do you disciminate based on race? If so, then you're a racist. If not, then you aren't.

Your political views do not decide whether or not you're racist.

Moj 'n' me Answered by phrannie on Oct 07, 2008, 01:41PM
4271 answers
Advisor-small

Ditto toadaly...

Do YOU think you are a racist??? Only you know for sure.

woofstock Answered by utopia on Oct 07, 2008, 05:10PM
1477 answers

Oh my god!!!
Did I fall asleep and go back in time?

Answered by wolfgun on Oct 08, 2008, 06:53PM
50 answers

Declaration of independence guess what southern states want a nation
Type of Government limited and a staterights they would be fighting for these to aswell not just slavery but I doubt anyone north or south fought for slavery. The real problem here is not you opinion but your understanding the best question what soldier in united states joins over political issues non. they join for education offers and generally the desire to defend ones nation. So inconclusion how can someone think soldiers of the south fought for a polotical issue and not independence and their home state =nation

i like fountains. Answered by melovesyouu on Nov 11, 2008, 03:03PM
589 answers

Actually, the civil war started because the South was upset that Abraham Lincoln was elected as president, as his name didn't even appear on most southern ballots. They felt that they were not getting enough representation if someone could get elected with no Southern votes. The confederacy was not formed about slavery or economy. It was about representation.

Answer this Question: "Im confederate does that make me racist?"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.



Politics Photos

i can always make you smile :) when im not being emo lolIf it don't make dollars - It don't make cents!im all dolled up

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
Im confederate does that make me racist?