How can I make my eyes look natural?

I want my eyes (like my eyelids and around my eyes) to look naturally dark. I use eyeliner and stuff but it always looks kinda un-natural. how can I make them look like that but more natural?

use make up...use an eyeliner that goes with you skin tone!

dont use sh*t...punch yaself in da face and ull get naturally dark eyes! lolz im joke im not sure consult cosmopolitan lolz

use brown eyeliner and brown mascara. use eye shadows with pink or lavender tones so it's not like ELECTRIC BLUE , like I use ;]

the naturalist you can go is don't wear any at all if you do were light brown mascara. Eyelinear. Eyeshadow. And don't listen to sk8ordiekindofguy don't punch your self. Lol

It looks unnatural cause it is. just stop and accept yourself.

eek, flats you make me sound like I hate myself. I dont, I just think it would look better if my eyes were a lil darker. thanx for all the advice everybody!
(and I think ill try the brown eyeliner instead sk8ordie, thanx, lolz)

Just use colours that go with your eyes more. Sometimes I use black eyeliner to darken up my eyes, but you cant tell. I do that by making sure my eyeliner pencil is really sharp and its almost like I'm applying it onto my eyelashes, but its just above them a tiny, tiny bit.