Sorry, that photo could not be found

Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

How do you explain the conflicting arguments?

Asked by led_zeppelin284 3 months ago, 18 answers.

The Bible says that on the sixth day of creation, God created animals. This would include dinosaurs. Also on the sixth day, humans were created. Logically, this means that humans and dinosaurs were living simultaneously. However, all anthropological and...

paleontological evidence shows that humans lived much (many million years) later than dinosaurs, based on many fossils that have been found. How do you explain the conflicting arguments?

kitty Answered by ty on Aug 22, 2009, 09:39PM
10127 answers
Advisor-small

Uhm how about the conflicting stories WITHIN the bible

Creation is described in Genesis 1:1 to 2:3 as occurring in six days:

Day 1: creation of light and its separation from darkness.
Day 2: separation of the sky and oceans.
Day 3: separation of land from the oceans; spreading of plants and grass and trees across the land.
Day 4: Creation of the sun, moon, and stars.
Day 5: Creation of sea animals and birds.
Day 6: Creation of the land animals. Creation of humanity, someone like ourselves (Living Bible).
Day 7: God rested. Followers of the Documentary Hypothesis believe this to have been a later addition, 4 placed there to give theological justification for the Sabbath (Saturday as a day of rest).

The Second Creation Story; Genesis 2:4 to 2:25: This is a different description of the creation of earth's life forms. Most mainline and liberal biblical researchers attribute this section to J, a writer who lived in the 9th century BCE (some say 10th century; others say after the Babylonian exile). Again, religious conservatives trace the authorship to Moses, and generally believe that this is a simple restatement of the earlier creation story. The author of Genesis 2 writes that
at first, there were no plants or grain present, because God had not yet sent rain.
God made Adam out of earth; this is a belief common to many early Pagan religions in the Middle East.
God created plants and herbs, Adam, the Garden of Eden, trees, birds and animals
God performed the first surgical operation, removing a rib from Adam and transforming it into the first woman, Eve.

Conflicts between the creation stories: There are some apparent inconsistencies between the first and second creation accounts:
There may be a conflict over the number of days over which creation happened.
Genesis 1:3 and subsequent verses say that God created the universe in six days.
In Genesis 2:4, some translations, including the King James Version, imply that it took one day. More details
In the first account, God created fruit trees before Adam and Eve; in the second account, God created Adam, then the fruit trees, then Eve.
In the first account, God created animals before Adam and Eve; in the second account, God created Adam. then the animals, then Eve.
Genesis 1:20 describes how God had the waters bring forth ...fowl ; in Genesis 2:19, God formed them out of the ground.
In the first account, God created the fish on the 5th day; in the second account, the fish of the sea were not created at all.

http://www.religioustolerance.org/ev_bibl.htm

1 person thought this was helpful
oh yeah Answered by crazyforspongebob on Aug 22, 2009, 09:29PM
198 answers

I dont believe that b/c I'm an Athiest. I think it's impossible b/c (as far as I know) it doesnt say in the Bible about the dinosaurs even though we know they were alive. so I don't know how to answer your question- ask your parents/family??

Most recent picture. Answered by katelyn on Aug 22, 2009, 09:30PM
90 answers

Yeah,
But see,
Being an Athiest makes NO sense,
How do you explain EVERYTHING that's been made and created?
Did it just appear?
No.

Answered by advisorssk on Aug 22, 2009, 09:34PM
259 answers

A day in the life of a human is very different (and probably WAYYY shorter) than a day in the life of God, I would suspect.

I would also suspect that humans don't always get their facts straight.

I would also assume that the time continuam would be very different for a being that does not die and does not necessarily live chronologically.

:P Answered by jezzelin on Aug 22, 2009, 09:40PM
150 answers

people are gonna believe what they want
if you believe it, it exists for you
if not,,then no

Clearing the Gene Pool Answered by bimjob on Aug 22, 2009, 09:47PM
3259 answers

Actually, yes, Katelyn. With a time span of almost 14 BILLION years and the various laws of physics, it does make sense.

If people want to claim 'God' as a spiritual force that gives souls, that's their business. But it is the right wing fundamentalist religions that try to use the bible to bend science.

Science is not trying to dictate to religion. It tries to examine and explain the natural world.
Creationists, and Young Earthers, and anti-evolutionists are doing a disservice to all by fighting so hard to shove their religious beliefs on everybody else.
Science and religion are not in conflict. They are totally different spheres of human thought, different disciplines entirely.

I do wish you well.
Take care and
Good Luck!!

1 person thought this was helpful
Answered by blueeyedgoddess on Aug 22, 2009, 10:40PM
170 answers

to katelyn being an atheist...there is scientifical evidence on how EVERYTHING was created if you paid attention in science class you would know that. and then you have the bible.. The bible is not proof it is a story. What actual proof do you have outside of the bible...and I mean actual proof not miracles and all that. And stop worrying about it...people believe what they want to believe they are not going to change their minds. People think the bible is right and people think evolution is right thats it...stop trying to explain or understand why people think the way they do about this or what is god and all that stuff because none of it can be explained or should be explained. it should be left a mystery.

Answered by blueeyedgoddess on Aug 22, 2009, 10:50PM
170 answers

another thing is not many people who believe in the bible believe in dinosaurs because they werent mentioned..so you kindof gotta believe in one or another...dinosaurs existed in BC not AD...B/C before christ...before the bible...the time line was actually made on christian terms...bc and ad...so it is all right to believe in both if you look at it that way. but people just dont.

Toadaly Answered by toadaly on Aug 22, 2009, 11:08PM
4232 answers

It's easy to explain...the Bible is simply always right no matter what! The Bible says pi = 3, so pi = 3, and that's that.

:snark:

Me - Created by maggot4 (Raven) Answered by ichibanarky on Aug 23, 2009, 04:16AM
9058 answers
Advisor-small

I would just like to know who wrote the book of genesis if nobody was there to see it...and even then, when did they learn to write?

Where do the stories come from...?

Wait - let me guess...God dictated and some fellow wrote it down. Magical.

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid (Online now) on Aug 23, 2009, 04:19AM
1770 answers

In response to the original question: Easy. The bible is either wrong, or allegorical.

Milan Answered by ifeelcrazy123 on Aug 23, 2009, 06:40AM
4944 answers
Advisor-small

***Being an Athiest makes NO sense,
How do you explain EVERYTHING that's been made and created?***

You develop theories and explain it by observing the world around you.

***Did it just appear?
No***

How do you KNOW that it didn't just appear?

Toadaly Answered by toadaly on Aug 23, 2009, 07:34AM
4232 answers

*** Being an Athiest makes NO sense, How do you explain EVERYTHING that's been made and created?

How was god created? If you allow for god to just exist uncreated, then why do you not allow for nature to just exist uncreated? god is not a meaningful answer to any well thought out question.

Answered by eternallife on Aug 24, 2009, 05:41AM
303 answers

Simple the dating systems have errors. That is why there is these conflicting arguments.

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid (Online now) on Aug 24, 2009, 06:23AM
1770 answers

***Simple the dating systems have errors. That is why there is these conflicting arguments.***

Yes, all measurements have margins of error, but not to the extent of being able to confuse 4.5 billion years with 6000! The error bars are on the order of about 1% rather.

And even if all dating methods were somehow shown to be invalid - something nobody has come even close to doing - there's a plethora of physical evidence that demonstrates the earth has to be millions of years old at an absolute minimum. Geologists have known this since the late 17th century, based on findings of successive strata of freshwater and saltwater fossils that prove that certain areas have been subsequently both below and above the ocean - more than once - a process that would take millions of years.

These geologists didn't have carbon isotope dating, of course, and this was even before Darwin published his theory of evolution. They simply followed the evidence and determined the earth had to be millions of years old at a minimum - a conclusion all subsequent science has confirmed.

A good, thorough takedown of the Young Earth Creationists' claims is here: http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009/08/yes_millions_of_years.php

And just to give non-YECs an idea of how absurd this is: 6000 years ago is approximately when the Babylonians invented Beer.

How far we have come... Answered by jimahl on Aug 24, 2009, 09:53AM
2603 answers

*** 6000 years ago is approximately when the Babylonians invented Beer. ***

So it was beer that started all this nonsense.

Eternallymisinformed, you really should stop embarassing yourself on these threads.

Answered by josh31west on Aug 27, 2009, 01:29PM

actually, EVOLUTION explains everything, the bible explains nothing, why??? Because the bible was written by committee 1500 years ago. Why were there no dinosaurs in the bible, because MAN didnt know about dinosaurs then, which just proves that MAN wrote the bible, not god. The big bang theory holds much more water than the bibles argument that some divine daddy is lurking in the clouds above us waiting for us to screw up so he can damn us to hell. Thats just CRAZY talk. They also thought the world was flat then and that if you sailed far enough, you would fall of. That why there also isnt anything in the bible about a little thing we like to call GRAVITY. There are many inconsitencies in the bible.
Look the whole thing boils down to one answer, early politics. In those days there werent elections or polls or caucuses. There was chaos and order, pagans, christians, and jews. Well christianity was on the rise much like islam throughout the world today, and in order to cease the chaos, Constatine united his nation under ONE religion, Christianity. Christianity won a popularity contest thats all, it was the most reasonable faith then, unfortunately that cant be necessarily said for it today. I am all for believing in whatever you want, but facts are facts. We are derived from NATURE, we are made up of elements, SCIENTIFICALLY. That doesnt mean there isnt a god, but for all we know, the Scientologists are right and we are just some Zoot 2nd graders Chem project. I hope he gets a C-...

Answered by jamlelong on Oct 07, 2009, 12:12PM
23 answers

Becuase the bible is all bulls*it.

Answer this Question: "How do you explain the conflicting arguments?"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


7 days of creation, Conflicting stories in the bible, Conflicting arguments, Adam and eve babylonians beer, How would you explain that god created the world and it wernt a big bang, How do jews explain dinosaures, Explain genesis in the bible, You explain the conflict:who is involved, Bible conflicting stories, Mss, How do you restate a hypothesis, Arguments no dinosaurs in bible, Conflicting stories within the bible, Sixth day creation, Believing two conflicting arguments simultaneously, Explain being right with god

Religion & Spirituality Photos

Honey please!!! Just calm down! Let Me Explain!That explains me ALOTi will never be able to explain how amazing you looked today

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
How do you explain the conflicting arguments?