What is your opinion on cutting?

Thunder Robot Asked by funadvice 6 months ago, 42 answers.

Is cutting wrong in your opinion? (person who in pain, sadness etc cuts them self)

Question closed | Ask a Health question

Answered by jello on May 27, 2008, 09:49PM
| 831 answers.

no. its their choice...

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 09:51PM
| 11739 answers.
Advisor-small

I don't see how cutting could in any way help the situation - why punish yourself just because things aren't going good. It seems like they would rather sit at home slitting their wrists instead of going out to get professional help. I was watching a show today and this girl admitted to doing it to get her teachers attention because nobody else in her life gave it to her so she went to that extent.

Answered by saucybaby on May 27, 2008, 09:53PM
| 1823 answers.
Advisor-small

I never understood why people chose to cut...If you're in physical or emotional pain why put yourself through more pain?

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 09:56PM
| 42399 answers.

when your a cutter it doesn't hurt it feels good when you see the blood come out it feels like thats the problem going away that sounds crazy but I know from past experience

Answered by jazlovestoskate on May 27, 2008, 09:57PM
| 3723 answers.
Advisor-small

usually, I beleive theres no reason for it
and those people could have gotten the help they needed without resorting to cutting themselves
but its just another way to release pain, it numbs the pain they already feel, and releases it...I guess it would help some people deal with there problems in there own way
but a lot of people doing it nowdays really have no reason to

Answered by saucybaby on May 27, 2008, 09:59PM
| 1823 answers.
Advisor-small

I think that by cutting its diverts the pain that they already feel

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 09:59PM
| 11739 answers.
Advisor-small

**when your a cutter it doesn't hurt it feels good when you see the blood come out it feels like thats the problem going away**

>> But how long does that happiness last?Not very long. Why not just go get professional help and the pain will be gone for good.

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:01PM
| 42399 answers.

when you cut that problem that your cutting out is gone forever its like a high it feels good so you dont stop because you start to depend

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 10:02PM
| 11739 answers.
Advisor-small

Thats enough to make my stomach turn.
I guess its something us non-cutters will never understand, and I'm fine with that because I'd never want to put myself through that.

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:03PM
| 42399 answers.

people see cutting as harming yourself its not it helps

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:04PM
| 42399 answers.

im not a cutter anymore I gave it up but it did help with what I was going thru

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 10:05PM
| 11739 answers.
Advisor-small

Clearly its harming yourself, how could anyone say its not...
Sounds like you need to do some research about the human body.

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:06PM
| 42399 answers.

in a physical way, yeah but in a mental way is healing

Answered by amblessed on May 27, 2008, 10:08PM
| 8686 answers.

Self-mutilation / Self-injury is wrong - seek other ways and/or professional help to help you cope with problems - by cutting you do not get rid of your problem/s forever - they'll still be there until dealt with.

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:09PM
| 42399 answers.

by cutting you deal with it

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 10:11PM
| 11739 answers.
Advisor-small

The scars are rather unattractive.

Answered by ty on May 27, 2008, 10:12PM
| 6743 answers.
Advisor-small

saucybaby - because emotional pain is a lot harder to bear than physical pain... it is complicated, a lot of the time self inflicted cuts dont really hurt that much (it really is not the same thing as an accidental cut), but yes it does divert pain...

jaz - no one cuts for no good reason, it may seem like it, but just as an alcoholic uses alcohol to deal with their issues, a cutter uses cutting... obviously it isnt a good solution, but it is never done for no good reason...

Steph - Because it is hard to admit that you need help, and sometimes it is impossible to believe that help is possible. And even with professional help, cutting (again like alcohol or any other destructive tool) is a quick fix, you just dont have to deal with the pain, no amount of therapy can replace a quick fix... Sometimes they feel they deserve the pain, sometimes people feel like their's something innately wrong with them... It really isnt as simple as attention seeking behavior that could be solved with a little therapy...

While I do understand why people cut, I am absolutely not advocating it... It obviously serves its purpose, but just as alcohol and other drugs are detrimental to health, so is self injury... At the end of the day it isnt the best solution, and there are better, happier ways to live...

Answered by saucybaby on May 27, 2008, 10:13PM
| 1823 answers.
Advisor-small

Like the saying goes time heals all wounds but when you cut you're left with permanent scars not so? And then as your life continues you will always have those scars to remind you of that tough situation you were in that lead you to cut..And then you have to find ways to cover/hide the scars left from cutting...So its like why go through all that drama...If you have a problem keeping it to yourself is quite dangerous..why not talk to someone about your problems like a friend, teacher, close parent or a professional counsellor..

That's just how I see it

Answered by funadvice on May 27, 2008, 10:13PM
| 42399 answers.

yah but they remind you that the past is real and will always be there

Answered by saucybaby on May 27, 2008, 10:14PM
| 1823 answers.
Advisor-small

ok

Back to top

Popular questions related to What is your opinion on cutting?