Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

What is the difference between a robot and an android?

Little Alien Asked by spiralbutterfly over 2 years ago, 12 answers.

I have always wondered why Data on Star Trek: The Next Generation says, I am not a robot, I am an android. What is the difference? Seriously.

Question closed
Answered by amblessed on Nov 05, 2007, 07:42PM
12243 answers

Definition:

Android - a mobile robot usually with a human form

Robot - 1 a: a machine that looks like a human being and performs various complex acts (as walking or talking) of a human being; also : a similar but fictional machine whose lack of capacity for human emotions is often emphasized b: an efficient insensitive person who functions automatically
2: a device that automatically performs complicated often repetitive tasks
3: a mechanism guided by automatic controls

Little Alien Answered by spiralbutterfly on Nov 05, 2007, 07:52PM
58 answers
Advisor-small

So what you're saying, amblessed, is that there is NO difference?

Answered by amblessed on Nov 05, 2007, 08:17PM
12243 answers

Not what I'm saying - that's how the Dictionary defined them - I notice android says 'human form' (possibly meaning 'skin covered') and robot says 'like a human being' (possibly meaning 'equipped with arms, head, etc but not 'human simulated skin covering') - just a guess :-) maybe we should phone home (Hollywood)

Little Alien Answered by spiralbutterfly on Nov 05, 2007, 08:23PM
58 answers
Advisor-small

LOL! Phone home...haha! That's funny! Thanks for your answer anyway. :D

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Nov 05, 2007, 09:14PM
53985 answers

I've always understood an Android to be a human-like robot, whereas a Robot can be any sort of shape or form - for example, there are robots which are used in car manufacture but they look nothing like people - usually they are long mechanical arms that can perform complex tasks, but don't have any legs, body, head etc. Robots can also be round discs which run around the floor too. Anyway, that's what I've always assumed the difference to be - an Android is a type of Robot.

If we translate that to ourselves, I guess rather than Androids and Robots its Humans and Animals, since scientifically we are supposedly a type of animal - I am not an animal, I am a Human might be your reply to Data!

Little Alien Answered by spiralbutterfly on Nov 05, 2007, 10:36PM
58 answers
Advisor-small

Hey danbob...thank you for your response. I had thought about what you said, but then a thought hit me. What about Star Wars? R2D2 was an android - remember Luke calling them 'droids? And R2 looks nothing like a human really. So that is the main reason for my asking the question. Sure, C3P0 looked kinda human, but not R2D2. Oh, and the robots in the movie I, Robot look very human-like, but they are called robots! Go figure! AAAHHH!

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Nov 06, 2007, 12:24AM
53985 answers

Hi spiralbutterfly... you are indeed correct about R2D2 and the I, Robot robots (as an aside, _why_ did they say they came from US Robotics? surely they look more like Apple made them - iRobot, anyone?). I didn't think of them... argh, it gets confusing now!

Perhaps its more related to function than appearance - if a robot is smart, as in it thinks for itself (or almost does) then maybe its an Android. But then I don't think that still works for the I, Robot robots - they seemed to be sort of smart. Certainly Andrew from Bicentennial Man was called an Android, and his function was similar to those from I, Robot. But then the I, Robot robots were not totally autonomous - they were able to be controlled and manipulated by that central computer thing (except for one), so maybe that doesn't quite make them Androids. Or maybe Hollywood thought I, Robot sounds better than I, Android. But certainly, Androids do seem to be a lot cleverer and autonomous (I.e. unreliant on others or other things) than Robots.

What are your thoughts on this?

Boat Show Answered by rodinc on Nov 12, 2007, 06:16PM

Hehe... Oh spiral, I thought you were working!!!
I think the terms have been used indiscrimately to define both androids and robots, the definitions from the dictionary (your first response) would have been very accurate some time ago, since, Androids (the name comes from the word Andro that means Man, Hombre, in greek or ancient greek) I guess were defined as humanoids, like in another of your responses, applied more to function (behavior) than shape. Through the extense library on your mind (filmography) I am sure you can spot many different Androids that have even showed human emotions at times.. so, you have, using all your responses of course a little more light... but not a final clarity on this... you will not have it ever, film makers will continue to use the terms as they see fit for your perpetual wondering... Hey! I hope you can sleep tonight!! hehe...

Answered by facelessdefacer on Mar 18, 2008, 04:38AM

Androids are typically - in fiction - comprised of parts which actually resemble the human anatomy - e.g. artificial blood and an artificial skin membrane. Robots are not; robots are intelligent machines which may resemble humans in their form, but not in their characteristics. One could say that an android is more sentient than a robot.

Answered by twiggy777 on Jun 16, 2008, 07:00PM
7 answers

the term and/r means human and -oid means like. so android means that it is human like. a robot can be any machine that performs a function, like the kind that weld car parts together

Answered by guyver01 on Jul 12, 2008, 11:45AM

Actually I think the main difference between androids and robots is the three laws of robotics.

1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
2. A robot must obey orders given to it by human beings, except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.

I think androids are more of the free will kind of ALF.

Say what you see... Answered by crashhound on Aug 11, 2008, 08:52PM

The word robot comes from the Czech word 'roboto' or 'labour'. A robot is a machine/servent/slave. The word android derives from the ancient Greek for 'man of the species'. So, as Twiggy777 states, Data is more than just a machine.

As for someone mentioning R2D2 C3P0, I'd say they were an/droids by quirk rather than design. R2's a repair droid computer interface. A machine. Nothing more. Note that no other R2 unit in Star Wars had as much of a character as he did. C3P0 had to have personality inbuilt due to his function as interpreter so it could be argued that he was an android.

Ask a question related to: "What is the difference between a robot and an android?"

Title: Give your question a title

Ask your Question: HTML is not allowed.

Category: Choose a category


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


Difference between android and robot, Difference between robot and android, Difference between androids and robots, What is the difference between a robot and an android?, Difference between a robot and an android, Difference android robot, Android robot difference, What is the difference between a robot and an android, Difference between robot and machine, Difference between an android and a robot, Difference between robots and androids, Robot android difference, Difference robot android, Difference between human and robot, What difference between robot android?, What's the difference between a robot and an android

Science Photos

i robotThunder RobotChiOdoS_RoboT

Science Questions


Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
What is the difference between a robot and an android?