Trashy or classy?

Guys what do you think makes a girl more attractive? If shes dressed really smart in a nice dress minimal make-up, or a girl in short skirts with loads of make-up? And girls would you go out with a guy who had a reputation?

ok well I think that it is better when a girl is comfortable in what she is wearing most of the time my girlfriend will wear a pair of basketball shorts and a t shirt I dont care what they wear but I think that it is gross when they have five pounds of makeup on their face that just shows me that they are insecure

I like girls who are more on the conservative side a not a lot of makeup that makes her look like a clown, sure I dont mind my girlfriend wearing skirts or revealing shirts but I would rather her like I said be conservative leave something for the imagination.