Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

To read or not to read that is the question

Unknown Art Girl Asked by xunknownartgirl 8 months ago, 6 answers.

People may not remember when I said People may jump out at me when I say this - but Twilight was not the best book-to-movie adaptation ever made. I may be biased in this though, seeing as I never became a huge Twilight fan. When I said it, it was...

because I never gave it a chance on the fact I am not a big romance in book type person.

That was before. Lately I have read about the books on wikipedia and it really had me thinking about reading the book because of the fairy tale romance quality. Im want to give it a chance, and at the same time im not sure.

So I was wondering besides what I read are the books as good as they say is the movie worth spending money on and watching?

Yeah do you? Answered by pwincess_irenemarie on Mar 18, 2009, 09:30AM
2854 answers

Books are ok.
Movie sucks.

happy

youknowyouloveme Answered by 2hot4yuh on Mar 18, 2009, 09:38AM
10 answers

I think it really depends on YOU. stephenie meyer's writing ability is quite poor, however, its the storyline thats EXTREMELY captivating. personally, I love the books, but the movie was a HUGE let-down. the actors are all pretty new, and lack good acting abilities. aswell, the camera-work and special-effects could have been greatly improved. the director has recently been replaced because of the poor movie ratings, meaning New Moon will be entirely different... and hopefully better.

Kate w/ David & Kyle "Breathe Carolina". !! Answered by twilightmom on Mar 18, 2009, 09:58AM
1215 answers
Advisor-small

Yeah, for a journalism major, her writing was very poor in Twilight---but, did improve some as the series went along. Totally captivating characters that draw you in from the very beginning.
The movie---ehhh. VERY small budget for a movie (like only 37 million, which sounds like a lot but is not for a movie that had the potential for serious extended theatre play). Special effects is what ruined it for me. The next movie is going to require even more special effects (wolf morphing) ansd budget only raised to 50 million---guess the production co.knows how to keep the money that's made when the sales start raking in. Too bad they're not as interested in customer satifaction? [ยค=

Gir rules. Answered by mikeh on Mar 18, 2009, 10:09AM
1710 answers
Advisor-small

Ten years ago, if anyone had said to me The hottest thing in 2009 is going to be Mormon pedophile abstinence vampires, I would either have thought I had been the victim of a Mad Libs or believed them wholeheartedly because this country has the literary taste of a dead dog. Twilight is the worst thing to happen to literature since Dan Brown figured out how to open Wordperfect.

love is a joke. Answered by anko924 on Mar 18, 2009, 11:18AM
93 answers

thank god there is someone else on this planet who hasn't submitted to the unhealthy obsession over twilight.
I have news for you: it is not the Shyt.
people tend to forget that it's just a book and not reality, so forgive me when I say that everytime I hear someone say , omg edward is sooo hot, I want him to take my blood and make it his! I want to strangle them.
the books...aren't bad. the writing style really sucked. and whether or not you decide to read them is your choice.
but bear in mind that edward and all of them are fictional characters. its not real.
sorry if I told you more than what you wanted to hear, lol.

Unknown Art Girl Answered by xunknownartgirl on Mar 18, 2009, 12:25PM
18 answers

You all been a big help, but I am still not sure the books sounded more interesting on wikipedia.

Answer this Question: "To read or not to read that is the Question"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


Mss?, The best book to movie adaptations?, Advice to read or not read the new moon book?

Entertainment Photos

most fun questionvoldemorts questionQuestion_It

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
To read or not to read that is the question