Tacky?

I have black hair, with human hair extensions. and they look very natural. In your opinion if I wore fake eyelashes with subtle make up, (no eyeliner and natural foundation) do you think it would look ok or do you think it would look tacky?

too much I think.

I think itd look nice...not that it matter what any of us think because its your decision its all about what YOU like. :]

Depends on the person. It can be tacky, or it can be done well.
I wouldn't risk it if you're unsure as to how it'll look.

Go with using eyeliner anyway

well try it if it feels good and looks good to you go for it if you dont like it well the only thing you lost was a few bucks its not like you are going for a tattoo! you can remove the make and lashes I say have fun and somthing new you never know you might realize you are the next top model! lol have fun ...

so long as the eyelashes arent too long or obviously fake I.e. feathery or jewelled
it should be fine