Pick between two guys

there are these two amazing guys. "bob" I have know 4 and a half years. he isnt a very cuddly guy, funny but sometimes anoyying, realy nice and I think we will get married in the far future. we had past relationships but they ended due to fighting. I think if I try again with him we are more older and smarter that that wont happen. then there is "jack". I have known him for 1 and a half years now. he cares about me a lot but sometimes lies and says he is going to do something and doesnt do it. these two guys are best friends which makes it so much harder. jack says he wont be friends with bob if he goes out with me becasue jack loves me. I like them both so much and I dont know who to pick! HELP!!

if you feel like you have to pick you shouldnt go out with either. if you really like someone you shouldnt be chosing involved.
but if I were you I wouldnt date jack because or the lying thing. that could lead to really bad things
and I think youre right about bob, try dating him later in life. you two may grow out of the arguing and fighting, but if hes, violent, dont even concider it