Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Our bodies are made of dirt

my own BONSAI tree!!! :D! Asked by athleta4life 2 months ago, 8 answers.

When you die, you return to the soil, ground, earth.

Today we know, that our bodies are made up of everything we can find on earth, in the ground.

We are made of water, calcium, iron, and so forth.

Thousands of years ago, on the account of...

genesis, the bible states that the lord grabbed the dirt/ dust/ clay, formed the human body, and breathed life into him.

People for thousands of years have believed that ...I came from the earth, and now I go back... When they die

Back then, thousands of years ago, they did not have the education or resources to understand what we do today, to know for a fact that our bodies are made up of: soil, earthly elements.

So if there is no god, then

Do you believe it was mere coincidence that humans thousands of years ago believed this which can be proven today? (not that god made man, but that man is made from dirt)??

Me and my little one (5 months old here) Answered by kdsmm on Sep 18, 2009, 11:48AM
586 answers

Interesting... But dirt has no life itself... neither does clay, rocks, iron, calcium, water... Even mud and minerals has no LIFE so to speak. So how did we, as mineral and earthen beings develop cognition or emotion, movement even?

Answered by question01 on Sep 18, 2009, 12:06PM
232 answers

That sounds good but thousands of years ago all people had to do was see the process of a decaying body to realize that when it breaks down it becomes dust. Dust and water becomes mud the bible doesn't say anything about calcium or water or anything else that makes the human body. I'm not trying to say that there is no God because I believe in him but it lacks facts if there was a picture of DNA in the bible I might be a little more lenient to believe.

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Sep 18, 2009, 01:13PM
1770 answers

Er, what would be the alternative? Seriously, if you didn't believe we're physically made out of natural resources found on earth, what else would we be made of? And where would it come from? It doesn't take a huge insight to realise that humans are made of the same stuff as everything else.

my own BONSAI tree!!! :D! Answered by athleta4life on Sep 18, 2009, 01:26PM
311 answers

yes but back then people also believed what we today think as unlogical and stupid. they would believe almost anything.

for example:

someone thousands of years ago wouldnt believe that humans were water or rocks or any form of element from the ground. they would think that we are completely foreign beings to this earth, on account that many simply believed that God just placed us on this earth, and since then we have nonstop reproducing.

people back then wouldnt believe that ***we're physically made out of natural resources found on earth***

you do now. based on the knowledge and education thousands of years efforts have come to be. but back then in those times, you would be like any other.

there wasnt really ***huge insight to realise that humans are made of the same stuff as everything else***

hell, even to this day, if I didnt learn from school that we are made from this stuff I would have never known til the day I died.

so understanding that, its hard to believe that our ancestors would have had such an open and skillful mind to understand otherwise.

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Sep 18, 2009, 01:31PM
1770 answers

***they would think that we are completely foreign beings to this earth, on account that many simply believed that God just placed us on this earth, and since then we have nonstop reproducing.***

No they wouldn't, because they'd have to face the fact that it's quite possible - easy, even - to create new human beings, without requiring assistance from space aliens.

Besides, many other cultures have creation stories that involve their god(s) creating the first human beings out of mud or something similar. Are you suggesting that those stories must also be accurate?

Toadaly Answered by toadaly on Sep 18, 2009, 01:36PM
4232 answers

*** Do you believe it was mere coincidence that humans thousands of years ago believed this which can be proven today?

You don't need to understand relativity in order to observe that plants grow out of dirt, and that animals either eat plants directly or eat other animals that eat plants. That life springs forth from dirt is a simple observation that can be made in any age.

Fruitylicious Answered by fruitylicious on Sep 22, 2009, 05:34AM
757 answers

I don't believe we were ever dirt to begin with...lol typical us (females) taking something precious from a guy (ribs) and trashing it... heheee.

Do find your questions very out there athleta4life... for someone who is only 2 years younger than I am, you certainly know your Bible inside out mate...awww you do puts this aussie chicky babe to shame.. happy

I have always believed we are ‘borrowing’ the beautiful bodies that God gave us and when we die, our bodies withers and decay and our souls hopefully ends up in heaven... The left behind bodies become dirt to fertilize the soil...soils aren't soils without good fertilizers I say..

(not including those two fine gentlemen above me thou)...LOL, im ready for the onslaught of negative attacks towards my answer / opinion...let me put my hard-hat on to cushion the incoming blows and have my stress balls ready on hand for the quick squeezes. wink

Answered by nlocnil on Oct 18, 2009, 11:25AM
198 answers

We know from scientific instruments that the elements can be found beyond our solar system.

Did god fill the universe with them for no reason at all?

Actually, remove god from the explanation and it all makes sense.

The heavy elements are made by a stars nuclear reactions and emitted at a stars death.
The gaseous and dusty remnants go on to form new stars, planets, and in our case the elements of life.

Humans weren't made from dirt, they evolved. All the way back to single celled organisms that developed from protocells, that formed in earth's early conditions from complex compounds.

Answer this Question: "Our bodies are made of dirt"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


Body made of dirt, Human made out of dirt, Are people made of dirt, What is dirt made of, Chapter in the bible where it says that our body is made from dirt, What our bodies are made of, Man made from dirt, Is the human body made up of dirt?, Are all of the elements of the body found in dirt?, Stuff made from dirt, Elements in the human body and dirt, Was humans really made from dirt, Our body and dirt, What makes our bodies so different from dirt?, People are made from dirt, Ery=man made from dirt

Religion & Spirituality Photos

look wat my mama madedirt modifiedsFULL BODY SHOT

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
Our bodies are made of dirt