What did you think of the harry potter book ending?

well I just finished reading the Harry Potter book..anyone else read it..what was your reaction to the ending and the whole book
Personally I liked it. It kept me on the edge the whole but I did get pissed when I found out that Lupin died. He was my favorite character.
oh well its just a book. so whats your thoughts..?

Yes I have read it. I have thouroughly enjoyed the series. Lupin and Tonks both died. It was sad, but it was good to know that Snape really WAS a good guy and he died with honor. I could not decide the entire time I was reading the book if I wanted Harry to die. Then when Harry did die, I was upset. I found myself relieved when he came back. I was very happy with the end, but I don't want it to end now. I know the epilogue was '19 years later' but I am just not satisfied. I want more! I want more adventures, mysteries, magic, I want it all. I am anxious for J.K. Rowlings to write more books, not just Harry Potter, anything. She is a great writer. Why was Lupin your favorite? My favorites are the Weasley twins and that was the most sad when the two became one. I have enjoyed your question.

Lol. Actually I enjoyed Fred and George as well. They made me laugh throughout the whole book more than anyone else in the book. Lupin was, I don't know, different. He has gone through so much and Tonk's parents didnt want her to marry Lupin. He suffered a lot mentally and all and his personality fits mines. Yes I was upset when I read that Harry died but he came out alive. The epilogue I have to say was something I was actually expecting to happen, I mean Ron getting married to Hermoine and Harry to Ginny. I loved the series. Trully did.

Oh my GOSH!!! I absolutely loved it...I was sobbing when harry was in the pensieve with Snape's memories...Great great great series. What will we do w/o harry?

I kind of wish you didn't say who died, because I haven't finished it yet!

:*(

I was just kidding about who died. Really. I promise. Cruel joke. So see, it will still be a surprise! Seriously though, REALLY sorry about that.

It's OK. Comes with the job, I suppose I still wouldn't trade FunAdvice for the world.

I loved the book to but in the epolode now who is running hogwarts??? it didnt say and I want that to be answer and why 19 years later why not 20 is there some reason for 19?

Monicacharlene: Harry never technically died he was in an inbetween.

I loved the ending it explaned a lot oh and just for records
HARRY POTTER IS GRAIT!!!
IT IS HORRIBLE THAT FRED , TONKS , LUPIN , HEDWIG AND MAD-EYE DIES BUT HEY SOMEONE HAS GOT TO !!!
'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'Neather Can Live While The Other Survives' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End ' 'I Open At The End '

Wooo Hooo

A H.P Freak I Am

I understood it to be that he died and the stone brought him back. He was after all, the one who could truly posses the deathly hallows. I know he and Voldermort were in some place and Harry was talking to Dumbledore, but I like thinking it was that he died and came back.

It was SO sad when Tonks and Lupin died when they just had a kid
I think J.K Rowling has created a grait world and all-though she might not write eny more books about Harry I think she should write more books about that world 'cause it would be a shame to waste it .
oh and by the way ...
J.K ROWLING IS GRAIT I NEVER USED TO READ BOOKS BUT THEN MY BEST MATE RECCOMENED THE HALF BLOOD PRINCE SO I BAUGHT IT AND READ IT IT WAS GRATE! THEN I READ THE ORDER OF THE PHOENIX AND THEN I BUYED THE REST AND READ THEM MORE THAN 40 TIMES HONIST
J.K ROWLING IS THE BEST AURTHER EVER THE BOOKS TAUGHT ME a lot AND I GOT A LEVIL 4a IN MY ENG SATS THANKS TO J.K ROWLING!!!
oh I am snickseeker but I got fed up with my nick

I am hopelessy obsessed with harry :]
I loved the book but I dont understand why she had to kill off Hedwig.
and fred and george were the best twins that ever existed. it stinks thats theres only one.
I wish she would make more books on the years in between the fall of voldemort and the years after, I keep reading the books over because I cant get enough.

AMAZINGNESS!! I was sobbing during the ending tho...

I LOVED the last book but I was really sad. I was sobbing when lupin, tonks and fred died!
Can't wait for the next movie lol

*Remus and tonks*

REST IN PEACE
by bianca potter
*LUMOS*

He was reluctant

She was so sure

He shook his head

She said, answer my call

I know there'll be risks but believe me, I'm ready

He laughed, that's not the point so please, just be steady

Then what is the point Lupin? She suddenly cried. Tell me the truth, don't you dare lie!

Listen to me Tonks, he said in suprise. You know the answer, you know there's no lies

I'm too old for you, it wouldn't be right

Oh please Lupin, come into the light

Please, can't you see? You're the one I want for me

You're strong, you're perfect, you are just right

Goodness, stop me now; I could go on all night

He laughed again, unconvincingly

And you're smart, you're funny and you're so darn pretty

But in this war, we're smack bang in the middle

It makes all relationships a terrible riddle

Tonks replied, that's even better

You know now we have to work together

Forever more do you want to roam, all by yourself? All alone?

Of course not, he said, shaking his head

This war, Tonks continued, taking his hand

It's about good and evil and you know what's sad?

The evil only want the best

They'll put our skills to the ultimate test

The thought of this gave Lupin a fright

Alas, he said, but you are right

Every word you have said is true

I know I've been hiding it but I love you

The love and happiness swelled in her heart

I love you too. Let us never part

The kissed like they had never kissed

Enjoying the feel of one anothers lips

*

After a few months, they were married

A binding love contract together they carried

But Lupin had rushed it, this marriage fling

He didn't feel ready for the whole 'together' thing

But still he stayed with her; they loved one another

Remus! One day she cried. You're going to be a father!

A father? He thought. We'll be a family?

This wasn't right. He had to find Harry

He found the young Potter at Grimmauld Place

I'm not ready, Lupin said, hands over his face

I rushed things with Tonks, I can't handle our baby

Would you mind if I helped with your quest, maybe?

Harry was rude but his words still wise

Once out of Grimmauld he made Lupin realise

Voldemort was Harry's quest, Lupin trusted him at any rate

But still he feared his friend's son's fate

So Remus accepted his place was not here

And apparated back to the wife he loved dear

*

Many months passed, the death toll grew

But one little life was born anew

Teddy Remus, born to Tonks and Lupin

Together and excitedly they called the group in

Congratulations! They cried to mother and father

Thank you, they said, we've never been prouder

We wish to make Harry the godfather of Teddy

We'll be sure to show you a picture when ready

*

Soon after, things became horribly wrong

Lupin had to spend less time with his son

Voldemort, his impatience growing

Travelled to Hogwarts, fully knowing

That Harry would be there, weak and slow

And that's when Voldemort would make his blow

But very little did he know

That Hogwarts would also take its stand

And fight the evil. Its passion was grand

Remus Lupin was there fighting alongside others

And amognst them he thought of his child's mother

And then what should appear

But a cry in his ear

Remus! It said

I'm here! Turn your head!

Lupin did as he was told

And saw his wife unfold

From the midst of other fights

Honey! He cried out to her. Now is not the night!

I'm in the Order too! I'm here to fight with you!

So shut up and hold me!

Together in a tight embrace, they looked into their lovers face

I love you she said

As I do you. He kissed the top of her head.

But without their realising

Death Eaters were rising

From corridors they came

Blocking the couple, they called their name

The Lupins! They sneered

Your end is near

But they only replied, death we do not fear

Wands were raised at each one of the lovers

There was a cry of Avada Kedavra!

And together, still hand in hand

Tonks and Lupin fell like rain

Never knowing their many brave efforts hadn't been in vain

*

Another hour later, a break before the last battle

Around so many bodies, the living's breath was rattled

There were screams as each empty body had been discovered

Finally, Tonks and Lupin had been recovered

The loss of these Aurors was unexplainable

The devastating shock of finding them under rubble

*

But the battle was won

And under the Sun

A funeral was held for two special friends

United together, they met a horrible end

Only one tiny person didn't cry that day

One little boy, his hair the colour of a blue jay

He was tightly held by his new carer

Her hair black, she couldn't bear

To see the name of her daughter on the grave

Daughter and husband, the witty and the brave

Were left in peace forevermore

*

And still now, if those times are old

Remembered by their hearts of gold

The way they fought

The way they cared

The love they bought

How it was shared

Never will there faces crease

Tonks and Lupin

Rest in peace

***

The night was still. Nothing stirred. Only the slight rustle of leaves on the ground, picked up gently by the little wind there was.
The night was chilly. A very thin mist hung millimetres above the ground.

A pair of yellow eyes surveyed the scene carefully. No graves were being visited: she would be safe. Stepping slowly and avoiding leaves, the vixen emerged from her hiding place behind an oak tree. Weaving her way between graves and mounds of earth, she pricked her ears for the hopefull sound of a rabbit or mouse. Instead she heard voices, whispers. Afraid for her safety, the vixen jumped back to her home and watched the newcomers with interest.

'I hope the kids don't wake up.' Harry was saying.

'They won't,' Ginny said, linking her arm with his. 'We'll be quick. It's too cold to be out anyway.'

'You didn't have to come' Harry said quietly.

'Don't be silly' Ginny said sternly. 'Tonks and Remus were my friends too. I'm always willing to pay my respects.'

They walked the rest of the way in silence. Finally arriving at their destination, Ginny placed the red roses she had picked on the way down on the grave.
Together, Harry and Ginny read:

Here lies Nymphadora Tonks and Remus Lupin
Beloved friends
Loving parents
Brave fighters
Will be sorely missed and remembered by their hearts of gold.
'Rest in peace' Harry and Ginny read aloud the last line.
Ginny wrapped her arms around Harry's neck and together they stood like that until a warm fire called them home.
Once the couple were out of sight, the vixen stepped out again, listening to their fading voices.
Again, she carefully stepped over leaves that might crunch and walked over to the grave that a few moments before had been visted.
She sniffed the roses with a dainty nose before looking up at the full moon

By Bianca Potter
Sorry I thought you would like this ,I did.

*NOX*

*Remus and tonks*

REST IN PEACE
by bianca potter
*LUMOS*

He was reluctant

She was so sure

He shook his head

She said, answer my call

I know there'll be risks but believe me, I'm ready

He laughed, that's not the point so please, just be steady

Then what is the point Lupin? She suddenly cried. Tell me the truth, don't you dare lie!

Listen to me Tonks, he said in suprise. You know the answer, you know there's no lies

I'm too old for you, it wouldn't be right

Oh please Lupin, come into the light

Please, can't you see? You're the one I want for me

You're strong, you're perfect, you are just right

Goodness, stop me now; I could go on all night

He laughed again, unconvincingly

And you're smart, you're funny and you're so darn pretty

But in this war, we're smack bang in the middle

It makes all relationships a terrible riddle

Tonks replied, that's even better

You know now we have to work together

Forever more do you want to roam, all by yourself? All alone?

Of course not, he said, shaking his head

This war, Tonks continued, taking his hand

It's about good and evil and you know what's sad?

The evil only want the best

They'll put our skills to the ultimate test

The thought of this gave Lupin a fright

Alas, he said, but you are right

Every word you have said is true

I know I've been hiding it but I love you

The love and happiness swelled in her heart

I love you too. Let us never part

The kissed like they had never kissed

Enjoying the feel of one anothers lips

*

After a few months, they were married

A binding love contract together they carried

But Lupin had rushed it, this marriage fling

He didn't feel ready for the whole 'together' thing

But still he stayed with her; they loved one another

Remus! One day she cried. You're going to be a father!

A father? He thought. We'll be a family?

This wasn't right. He had to find Harry

He found the young Potter at Grimmauld Place

I'm not ready, Lupin said, hands over his face

I rushed things with Tonks, I can't handle our baby

Would you mind if I helped with your quest, maybe?

Harry was rude but his words still wise

Once out of Grimmauld he made Lupin realise

Voldemort was Harry's quest, Lupin trusted him at any rate

But still he feared his friend's son's fate

So Remus accepted his place was not here

And apparated back to the wife he loved dear

*

Many months passed, the death toll grew

But one little life was born anew

Teddy Remus, born to Tonks and Lupin

Together and excitedly they called the group in

Congratulations! They cried to mother and father

Thank you, they said, we've never been prouder

We wish to make Harry the godfather of Teddy

We'll be sure to show you a picture when ready

*

Soon after, things became horribly wrong

Lupin had to spend less time with his son

Voldemort, his impatience growing

Travelled to Hogwarts, fully knowing

That Harry would be there, weak and slow

And that's when Voldemort would make his blow

But very little did he know

That Hogwarts would also take its stand

And fight the evil. Its passion was grand

Remus Lupin was there fighting alongside others

And amognst them he thought of his child's mother

And then what should appear

But a cry in his ear

Remus! It said

I'm here! Turn your head!

Lupin did as he was told

And saw his wife unfold

From the midst of other fights

Honey! He cried out to her. Now is not the night!

I'm in the Order too! I'm here to fight with you!

So shut up and hold me!

Together in a tight embrace, they looked into their lovers face

I love you she said

As I do you. He kissed the top of her head.

But without their realising

Death Eaters were rising

From corridors they came

Blocking the couple, they called their name

The Lupins! They sneered

Your end is near

But they only replied, death we do not fear

Wands were raised at each one of the lovers

There was a cry of Avada Kedavra!

And together, still hand in hand

Tonks and Lupin fell like rain

Never knowing their many brave efforts hadn't been in vain

*

Another hour later, a break before the last battle

Around so many bodies, the living's breath was rattled

There were screams as each empty body had been discovered

Finally, Tonks and Lupin had been recovered

The loss of these Aurors was unexplainable

The devastating shock of finding them under rubble

*

But the battle was won

And under the Sun

A funeral was held for two special friends

United together, they met a horrible end

Only one tiny person didn't cry that day

One little boy, his hair the colour of a blue jay

He was tightly held by his new carer

Her hair black, she couldn't bear

To see the name of her daughter on the grave

Daughter and husband, the witty and the brave

Were left in peace forevermore

*

And still now, if those times are old

Remembered by their hearts of gold

The way they fought

The way they cared

The love they bought

How it was shared

Never will there faces crease

Tonks and Lupin

Rest in peace

***

The night was still. Nothing stirred. Only the slight rustle of leaves on the ground, picked up gently by the little wind there was.
The night was chilly. A very thin mist hung millimetres above the ground.

A pair of yellow eyes surveyed the scene carefully. No graves were being visited: she would be safe. Stepping slowly and avoiding leaves, the vixen emerged from her hiding place behind an oak tree. Weaving her way between graves and mounds of earth, she pricked her ears for the hopefull sound of a rabbit or mouse. Instead she heard voices, whispers. Afraid for her safety, the vixen jumped back to her home and watched the newcomers with interest.

'I hope the kids don't wake up.' Harry was saying.

'They won't,' Ginny said, linking her arm with his. 'We'll be quick. It's too cold to be out anyway.'

'You didn't have to come' Harry said quietly.

'Don't be silly' Ginny said sternly. 'Tonks and Remus were my friends too. I'm always willing to pay my respects.'

They walked the rest of the way in silence. Finally arriving at their destination, Ginny placed the red roses she had picked on the way down on the grave.
Together, Harry and Ginny read:

Here lies Nymphadora Tonks and Remus Lupin
Beloved friends
Loving parents
Brave fighters
Will be sorely missed and remembered by their hearts of gold.
'Rest in peace' Harry and Ginny read aloud the last line.
Ginny wrapped her arms around Harry's neck and together they stood like that until a warm fire called them home.
Once the couple were out of sight, the vixen stepped out again, listening to their fading voices.
Again, she carefully stepped over leaves that might crunch and walked over to the grave that a few moments before had been visted.
She sniffed the roses with a dainty nose before looking up at the full moon

By Bianca Potter
Sorry I thought you would like this ,I did.

*NOX*

WHOOPS POSTED IT TWICE SORRY :D

it was ok. why didnt it tell us what happened to him. did he become an aura or what. she should of told us. It feels so wierd noing there wont be any more stories

I read over the summer and I finished it 2 days I love the ending I mean ron and hermione and harry and ginny they were sooo perfect for eachother but I hated it when fred dies he was my favorite twin!

I liked the actual book part but I didn't enjoy the epolouge so much. I thought that it could have used a little more detail. I felt that Rowling showed her amateur writing because the book has a totally different style than the epolouge. well other than the whole non-detail thing I liked it.

dont laugh but I cried when dobby died lol

just finished reading it. it was really good, I couldnt put it down for days. stayed up till 3 reading it, got up first thing in the morning and started reading it again. it was great. I too thought the very end could have used more detail: what harry was doing now, who ran Hogwarts, who was running the whole wizarding world, all that. and it sucked about all them dying, pretty sad. but I think I would have found it more...epic if Harry had died. but only if Voldemort had been taken out after it. it would have been a lot sadder if he had taken his life to save the rest of the wizards and his friends, but I guess it would have seemed more heroic in a way. and I had heard that Rowling had written a separate ending, which was turned down, so she had to rewrite the ending...andbody else heard something like this? if its true, I would like to see what the original ending would have been

lethel book! the reason the epilouge said 19 years later is because the book is set in the early 90's. most people dont know that but now you do!

I was depressed for a week when Sirius died at the end of book 5. I wanted so much for Harry OR Neville to kill Bellatrix (that B***H) in book 7 as she tortured neville's parents and KILLED SIRIUS. I thought it was weird that Mrs. Weasly ended up killing her in the end. I didn't like that part. But I like how the school battled together in the 7th book. I also didn't like how one of the twins died. THEY WERE THE BEST. Rowling just killed off way too many characters that I loved.

Aw it was so sad

I love Lupin and it was SO sad when he died cus he was one of my fav characters ANd he just had Teddy

Was sad when Sirius died in the 5th book too cus he was another of my fav characters

Annd poor Dobby and Hedwig AND Fred

In a way Sirius and Lupin, and Pettigrew are all reunited with James, even though Pettigrew was a bad guy, he coodn't kill Harry when he tried to strangle him, so all 4 mates bk together probly havin a beer

I luv the movies but im ok with it I can watch them wenever my lil sister on the other hand she is devastated shes in luv with Harry Potter she says thats her husband. hes ugly I id go 4 Ron!

I luv the movies but im ok with it I can watch them wenever my lil sister on the other hand she is devastated shes in luv with Harry Potter she says thats her husband. hes ugly I id go 4 Ron!

I luv the movies but im ok with it I can watch them wenever my lil sister on the other hand she is devastated shes in luv with Harry Potter she says thats her husband. hes ugly I id go 4 Ron!

I luv the movies but im ok with it I can watch them wenever my lil sister on the other hand she is devastated shes in luv with Harry Potter she says thats her husband. hes ugly I id go 4 Ron!

Don't worry cantthinkofanamebiotch, so did I. It was sad.