Which eyeliner is better, solid or liquid?

wich is better, solid or liquid? I asked this before but I didnt get any answeres and I need to know.

Thanks!!

maybelline has a pencil liner that you have to sharpen, it doesn't normally run down my face and I go swimming a lot.

in my opinion solid eyeliner is better and not the kind that twists I like the kind you have to sharpen

depends on what brand..also the tip..I prefer solid but I still use both once in a while.

I use solid... I didnt know there was liquid...

Depends on what look you are looking for. A liquid liner used to draw a line over the top of the brow and used to give a cats eye look can be striking. Where as a solid line is good if you want to just define the natural outline of the eye.

does anyone have any advice on brands? like that dont run down your face too much??

try annabelle waterproof liners you can buy them at walmart and they are amaaazing they are the only kinds I will use I have a huge box of all annabelle liners

maybelline and napoleon have a great range of liners and mascaras which wont irritate or run easily and are easy to apply. (im in australia so not sure whats available in your area)

I would say solid, but I do have liquid eyeliner (hate it), it's by N.Y.C. don't get it, it's cheap if you do want it though.

I like things about both, but I normally use solid. Solid is easier to apply and lasts longer, in my opinion.

I use the liquid one from avon. it goes on really clean.

I use Solid. My eyes tend to water a lot if I use liquid.
Darn allergies lol

Solid is best.Liquid smears and looks racoon like