Welcome!


Join more than 152,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Cutter feels delusional

Me and my brother Asked by asdfg63plus1 about 1 year ago, 23 answers.

Hey, I have a friend who recently cut her wrists, she said she made a few cuts, but they weren't deep, and she wasn't attempting suicide, but since then (she did it on Sunday) she has been delusional and has been very forgetful. Is this natural or is...

something wrong?

Answered by amblessed on Nov 26, 2008, 08:52AM
12232 answers

Her parents and/or professional needs to be informed asap so they can ascertain if there is a problem - here's some depression info: http://www.helpguide.org/mental/depression_teen_teenagers.htm
Self-injury: http://www.helpguide.org/mental/self_injury.htm

Here's a 24hr a day number if she wants to just talk, they'll listen, or pray if she likes:
1-800-488-4673

You're a good friend, I wish you all the best !!

1 person thought this was helpful
The 'Truth'!!! Be 'saved'!!! Answered by reb1312 on Nov 26, 2008, 08:47AM
618 answers

Girls at that age are very over-dramatic...to be honest I wouldn't think anything of it, but that's just me.

0 people thought this was helpful
Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 09:02AM
152 answers

Thanks for the answers, but she isn't depressed, her life just sucks a whole lot right now. I just wish there was more I could do to help, but she won't let me help.

0 people thought this was helpful
Answered by kjk09 on Nov 26, 2008, 09:12AM
33 answers

hey I know how you feel I also have had a friend that cuts. right now it doesn't seem like it's too big of a problem but I would try and talk to her about stopping and maybe why she feels the need to do it. if she doesn't stop or things seem to get worse I would recommend telling an adult, her parents, a school cousoler, I don't know just someone that can help you out. ya, I know it's going to suck to rat out your friend and she mite even be mad at you but in the end if she really is your friend she will probably thank you!

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 09:32AM
152 answers

She doesnt do it often, she's only done it twice in the past 2 months, but that's a lot better than what it used to be. But when we first met, we talked a lot and about some deep things and she told me that, and I got her to promise that she wouldn't, but even though she broke that promise twice, I can almost guaruntee that if she didn't promise, she would have done it a lot more and probably with worse intentions =( But she knows that I'm always there for her and that I love her, so I hope things get better.

kitty Answered by ty on Nov 26, 2008, 09:33AM
10169 answers
Advisor-small

Girls at that age are very over-dramatic...to be honest I wouldn't think anything of it, but that's just me.

yes, obviously you've had no mental health training whatsoever...

as to your friend, she may have depression with psychotic features, obviously the delusions are not a good sign... and the cutting has nothing to with the delusions or the forgetting (at least not directly), but it may be a sign of the depression... right now the cutting may not even be the worst of her problems...

psychotic features are a bad sign... someone needs to be informed asap

1 person thought this was helpful
Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 09:59AM
152 answers

='( well that really sucks to hear. But it's weird, she isn't always sad, it's kind of like a bi-polar sadness, one day shes all fine and dandy, the next, life really sucks and she's really sad. But the delusions and forgetfullness started the day after she cut, so I was thinking it had something do from it. I talked to another friend who used to cut and she said that she sometimes felt the same way and it was just natural, but it still sucks because she really doesn't remember anything from yesterday, and the things she does remember, are the bad things that went on. But we used to go out, and broke up due to certain circumstances, but there is the possibility of us getting back together and we still say that we love each other and all that, but yesterday, told me that she really really loved me and I told her I felt the same, and also, she said that she actually thought about wanting to go back out with me, but she doesn't remember any of that today, she only remembers the bad things that happened

The 'Truth'!!! Be 'saved'!!! Answered by reb1312 on Nov 26, 2008, 11:54AM
618 answers

Fact:

People cut for attention. That is the only REAL reason they do it. They may think it's them cutting to make the emotional pain go away, but it's not. It's them crying out for help/attention, and almost admitting they have some kind of problem, whether it be they think they're fat, or their father rapes them.

The reasons people cut can vary, however the UNDERLYING/REAL reason is for help/attention.

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 12:02PM
152 answers

Well if what Reb1312 said is true, what's the point of cutting yourself if you only tell like 3 people. Trust me, she gets plenty of attention from me and one other guy she showed because he has a thing for her, and I used to go out with her and we talk every day. But she also told my brother, but he isn't someone she wants more attention from, she just trusts him.

The 'Truth'!!! Be 'saved'!!! Answered by reb1312 on Nov 26, 2008, 12:27PM
618 answers

I don't think you understand.

I used attention in the sense that she needs help. As in treatment, whether it be by a GOOD therapist, or a psychiatrist.

For the people who are truly cutters (although I've never experienced it, I'm sure some people 'cut' to fit in), whether they want to admit it or not, they are doing it in hopes that one person will notice it and help.

Just because she told ONLY 3 people doesn't mean she's doing it so she can brag about it and tell other people. That isn't, at all, what I meant.

The only other way I could possibly be more clear is to give you an example.

Say this girl (if she had a name, I didn't see it, sorry) goes to school and someone sees her cuts. That second person goes to the school's guidance area/office area and tells someone about it in confidence in order to help that girl. That girl is brought down to the guidance area and talks to at least a somewhat professionally trained, in so many words, therapist. From there, the guidance councilor will refer her to a therapist. Since I am not a guidance councilor, I don't know the specific rule of thumb when it comes to cutting, but, I used to be a drug addict, and from that I know, if it's life threatening, the guidance councilor must tell her parents. If not, the guidance councilor could tell her parents she's depressed and it would benefit her to speak to someone. That way, they don't need to know the real issue, and she gets to see a therapist.

Do you now see the picture I am trying to paint for you?

When I say people cut for attention, I mean its a cry for help.

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 12:37PM
152 answers

Oh, I'm sorry for the misunderstanding, and sorry if I sounded like I was trying to put you down, that is not at all what I was trying to do. I'm just worried for her, I really wish there was more I could do to help, but she isn't letting me, she knows I can help, but she isn't letting me.

The 'Truth'!!! Be 'saved'!!! Answered by reb1312 on Nov 26, 2008, 02:02PM
618 answers

Who cares? Help her anyway. Sometimes no means yes. Again, I'd have to physically be in front of her to assess her so to speak, but while she may be saying No don't help me, she may mean Please help me.

Complicated, I know. If I were you, I would push the subject a little bit and see where it gets you - just don't push it TOO much or she might get pissed off and stop talking to you.

All in all - be friendly, but aggressive.

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 03:22PM
152 answers

Yea, I know that pretty much every time she says I'm fine I know for a fact that she isn't, and it's not that I am not trying to help her, she just isnt telling me anything or giving me any information that will allow me to help her. I usually am kinda pushy because I want to try and help and I want to know how she's really doing, but she just keeps saying I'm fine or I'll be fine so she basically admits something being wrong, but she won't tell me what it is.

Answered by kissestotheheart on Nov 26, 2008, 05:04PM
36 answers

I know you don't want her to be mad at you, but at this point I tihnk you should tell an adult. You can even ask them to not tell her it was you who alerted them. I doesn't have to be her parents, although that would be the best choice. It could be your parents, a responsible adult sibling, or maybe your youth pastor if you go to church.

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 05:54PM
152 answers

Yea, I'm starting to think I should do that. I definitely wouldn't tell her mom though, she'd have at least 5 cows, and I bet her dad wouldnt care. But I might tell our youth pastor, I know he can help, he's a licensed counselor and all. Thanks for the idea, I'm sure it would help. Now I just need to pluck up the courage and actually do it.

The 'Truth'!!! Be 'saved'!!! Answered by reb1312 on Nov 26, 2008, 06:13PM
618 answers

Your youth councilor idea is a good one.

GL.

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 06:50PM
152 answers

Yea, I think I might go with that if things don't get sorted out and better by the next time I see him. Thank you for all the answers and thank you all for bearing with my complaining! =D If you still have any suggestions, I'd be more than happy to hear them.

kitty Answered by ty on Nov 26, 2008, 09:29PM
10169 answers
Advisor-small

Fact:

People cut for attention. That is the only REAL reason they do it. They may think it's them cutting to make the emotional pain go away, but it's not. It's them crying out for help/attention, and almost admitting they have some kind of problem, whether it be they think they're fat, or their father rapes them.

yeah? according to whom? you can say Fact all you want before a sentence, it doesnt make it true... that is complete inaccurate, most people who cut dont tell other people... your ignorance completely amazes me... especially given your age... it may be forgivable if you were younger, but at your age you shouldnt be talking about anything you dont know... and it's COUNSELOR... but that really is besides the point... cutting is a coping method (I'll grant you a poor one) not an attention seeking device... it doesnt mean the person does not need help however... and yes an adult who actually knows what they're talking about (you know someone actually trained in mental health who wont jump to conculsions about the meaning behind the cuts) is probably your best bet... most people dont really know much about self harm... it isnt their fault, it isnt something that is talked about and even most medical doctors assume it is either an attention seeking device or a sucide attempt... unless one has actually received training it is hard to understand... so I'd be careful who you pick to talk to... a mental health professional is probably best

Me and my brother Answered by asdfg63plus1 on Nov 26, 2008, 10:12PM
152 answers

Well, my youth pastor is a licensed and professional counselor, he gets people all the time talking about depression, so I'm sure he can help. I have a random question for anyone still listening to me complain, but is it normal that I have honestly prayed to God asking Him to take all her hardship and pain and bring it on me and make her happy and knowing that I'd be able to handle it all a lot better probably?

Answered by moon063008 on Nov 26, 2008, 10:33PM

I used to cut... its not all about attention... I done it for 6yrs before I told anyone... and I only told one person... my boyfriend... who helped me thro it... my advice is comfort and understand... help your friend find alternatives... give her rubber bands to snap... she will snap out of it...
how long has this been going on tho...

kitty Answered by ty on Nov 26, 2008, 10:48PM
10169 answers
Advisor-small

I'd post that as a seperate question in the religious section... you'll probably get more responses...

I'm not very religious so I cant answer it from that pov, but you seem like a good person and a good friend, and she's lucky to have you around...

Answer this Question: "Cutter feels delusional"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.



Health Photos

the best feeling in the world is for a guy to hold your waste!Feeling blue ...?i only just show what i feels...

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
Cutter feels delusional