Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Is there a good alternative to cow's milk for my 1-year-old?

Asked by trurasta over 2 years ago, 13 answers.

Hello I have a one year old son and I do not want to give him cows milk, I was thinking maybe soy milk. Do you have any suggestions. I breastfed until two weeks ago and now he has soy formula. What do you suggest please tell me... Thank you so much.

woohoo Answered by texaskimmie on May 30, 2007, 08:09AM
1905 answers
Advisor-small

I vote for Goat's Milk as well. It is very easy on a child's digestive system.

1 person thought this was helpful
Whiteboard portrate Answered by filletofspam on May 24, 2007, 07:26AM
2970 answers
Advisor-small

Since your son is 1 if he is eating solid foods well he doesn't need formula.

I worry a little about giving kids that young soy. If he develops a soy allergy than this will make his life very difficult since soy is in so many things. Rice milk is the milk least likely to produce allergies. I'd wait another year or two before introducing soy products into his diet (same with peanuts).

Answered by momof2girls on May 24, 2007, 12:26PM

Both of my girls had some sort of allergy to my breast milk and were on an extremely hypoallergenic perscription formula. We started giving both of them rice milk 1st with rice cereal at about 7 months. Then we switched to soy milk and they are both fine with it.
My pediatrician recommended giving them 1 oz, mixed in with formula once a day for 3 days and if there is no reaction to switch them over to straight soy milk.
I hope this helps.

This is not a self portrait. Answered by skatedaddy9 on May 24, 2007, 12:32PM
146 answers

One of my boys drank rice milk for a few years. He is not bothered by cows milk anymore so I guess he out grew his allergies.

Yup, that's me! Answered by istrancis on May 24, 2007, 01:52PM
8 answers

I recommed goats' milk. I'm a nineteen year-old student, and I've been taking goats' milk for a while now as a replacement for cows' milk in order to help clear up my eczema, and it seems to be working.

Also, goats' milk is believed to be more beneficial for the human metabolism, which would perhaps make for a smoother transition from mother's milk to commercial milk as far as your son's metabolism is concerned.

Please bear in mind that I'm not an expert on this, so you should probably double check with your family GP or a public health nurse first. I hope my advice helps though!!! Best of luck!

1 person thought this was helpful
Tinker bell Answered by jody on Jun 06, 2007, 03:58AM
88 answers

I was allergic to milk when i was a baby, my parents gave me goats milk which worked wonders.

Just_Me Answered by mrsbee on Jun 06, 2007, 08:33PM
5 answers

What I did with my son was I went straight to Soy Milk the one in the red carton which is the regular sometimes as a treat I will buy the Soy milk in the blue carton which he really likes bc its vaniella flavor but it has to much suger for me. Anywho we tried cows milk when he was one but no matter how we gave it to him he would throw it up it scared to doo doo outta me bc he would just start throwing it up in the middle of the night while sleeping. Anywho my husband did research and found that Soy milk was the best. The very first day we gave it to him we didnt mix it with formula he did GREAT. Now he's two and he can do regular milk but Soy is so much healther and so were sticking to it happy hope this helps

Me Answered by vachick08 on Mar 05, 2008, 11:36AM
79 answers

If he's one he doesn't need formula anymore. I agree with the above (either try goats milk or soy) it should be fine. Just one question tho, why not cow's milk?

Answered by nelly723 on Jun 02, 2008, 11:23PM

hi I have a two-year old girl and I give her silk very vanilla soy milk. she loves it because it is sweet and very good tasting and it has all the vitamins your baby will need plus protein. Hope this helps and God Bless you and your family.

Answered by mimi2bmama on Jun 08, 2008, 04:23PM
12 answers

goat's milk is best because its the closest to breast milk

1 person thought this was helpful
Answered by mamastude on Aug 13, 2008, 07:08PM

I am feeding my son hempmilk, it is very close to cows milk but is made out of seeds, it is very healthy and my son loves it, he has an allergy to milk and soy and had to be on a very expensive formula until one and I was looking to relieve the check book a little, you can get it at whole food store for about $4.00 a box for 32 oz, still a little expensive but not like the formula, he's my million dollar baby!

Answered by justamom on Aug 14, 2009, 06:54AM

I have read that soy milk has too much estrogen to give to a growing baby, especially baby boy. And that there is not enough fat in it for babies under 3. My GP also said that the sodium content of Goats milk was too high for a baby. SOrry this doesn't offer any suggestions.

Answered by maali on Sep 19, 2009, 01:00AM

hi,I have 1 year old girl,she was on forula milk and I shifted her to fresh cow milk,only in the morning so that she dont feel full by lunch meal and we give more solid food,
am concern about which is better to continue fresh or to shift again to formula as its fortified,
my babay hb is normal 12.and some time she is having constipation,I referred that to formula milk at bed time tha she is taking
and am concern that she get cow milk allergy and is it common after 1 year old

Answer this Question: "Is there a good alternative to cow's milk for my 1-year-old?"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


Alternatives to cow's milk for babies, Alternative to cow's milk for babies, Best milk for 1 year old, Alternatives to cow's milk for toddlers, Alternatives to cows milk for babies, Cows milk alternatives for babies, Goats milk for 1 year old, Best milk for one year old, Alternative to cows milk, Alternatives to cows milk for toddlers, Soy milk for one year old, Milk alternatives for 1 year old, Cow's milk alternatives for babies, Alternatives to cow's milk, Alternative to cow's milk, Cow milk alternatives for toddlers

Kids Photos

Yes its a cough... i.m just a little horseold last year i was turnt me 2 years ago

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
Is there a good alternative to cow's milk for my 1-year-old?