Twilight (book vs movie)

The movie sucked. Horribly.

Rob playing Edward is GREAT!

I agree with you… I don’t think that anyone could be perfect for the role of Edward… But I feel okay saying that they could have picked a better guy for the job. He’s just not what I pictured at all, not even close lol. I loved the book, and I’d like to think that the movie will live up to it’s potential. But…almost every movie that I’ve seen that was once a book just isn’t the same. I can’t wait for the movie and find out. It couldn’t ruin the book, it might ruin the idea of the book for someone who hasn’t read it..If that makes sense. You always have to read the book before the movie, that’s how I think anyway.

I think he’s okay.. I did kind of prefer the guy chosen by stephenie meyer, and also the girl, but saw the trailer and the pictures, they arent that bad. robert is pretty hot ans he does look misterious. I think it’ll be okay, it will ruin the book, because they changed some things, and well, that always happends, like in all harry potters. but we all want to see the movie anyways right?

I like robert as edward but kristen for bella is not good I really wanted emily browning for bella but o well I’m acutally really scared for the movie because the books are aways better then the movie I didn’t really want them to do a movie any way because its better in your imagination

I think Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson are both PERFECT for the parts of Bella and Edward. Im VERY glad she didn’t pick Emily Browning. (no offence. I just think Kristen is better.) I love the movie, I bought it and I’ve watched it 6 times so far, But it’s NOTHING like the book and I think it could have been better. I still love it.

I love the book it is amazing adn the film was really really good too. I thinkk rob and kristen are gr8 as Edward and Bella and I think that they were the best for the parts!!! :)

I like robert as edward but kristen for bella is not good I really wanted emily browning for bella but o well I’m acutally really scared for the movie because the books are aways better then the movie I didn’t really want them to do a movie any way because its better in your imagination

lol my friend Paris would love to answer this question… she could go on for hours.

But im only like 10 chapters in at the moment.

not sure yet ;)