Do you like pencil or ink eyeliner more?

I prefer ink eyeliner because I feel like it applies on more smoothly and gives a finer line. You can be more strategic with it. There are some pencil eyeliners that I like too but I just don’t like sharpening it frequently. Pencil liners usually give a more natural and softer look but since I like my liner dark, I like ink better. :)

Liquid. I hate pencil it smudges much too easily even the ones that say they are waterproof or smudge proof.

Depends. For my top eyelid I will only use liquid. It works SO well, & you can be so dynamic. I will only use pencil for my waterlines. It’s soft.

ink!

I am a guy and i find ink eyeliner sexy, attractive, bold and natural whereas pencil eye liners are too fake and noticeable.

For the longest time I preferred the pencil eyeliner. Once I became a beauty consultant at Merle Norman I started using a cream eye liner that you apply with a brush. You can get the precision you need and it stays on 10x longer. So to answer your question, neither. Everyonce in a while I will still use a pencil on my water line though. Just because I have sensitive watery eyes.

What do i prefer, ink or pencil eye liner? I think i like the pencil eyeliner because it goes on a lot smoother and with the ink you have to worry about it getting in your eyes.

I like roll on. Pencil is too hard to use and liquid is too messy.

personally, if you get a really good pencil eyeliner it is good. i use miss.sporty plain black eyeliner and its not expenive but its definatley one of the best pencil eyliners i have used. whereas on the other hand, if you find a really good liquid eyeliner that works stick to that!. i feel that liquid eyeliner is too horrible to use and too messy if you have a full face off makeup on. so i always use pencil:)X

personally, if you get a really good pencil eyeliner it is good. i use miss.sporty plain black eyeliner and its not expenive but its definatley one of the best pencil eyliners i have used. whereas on the other hand, if you find a really good liquid eyeliner that works stick to that!. i feel that liquid eyeliner is too horrible to use and too messy if you have a full face off makeup on. so i always use pencil:)X