Should you use liquid or solid eyeliner

What do you guys think?

Well,I use both.
But I find that the stick eyeliner tends to smudge an smear all over my face if I sweat or if its hot out.
So right now,Im using waterproof liquid eyeliner.Its nater and it doesnt smudge.
but if your not careful,you could get it in your ye,which hurts.

I use both too. I use liquid on the tops of my lids and solid on the inner bottom of my lids.

I use liquid every day to paint on my eyebrows, but I don't really line my eyes. If I do, I use the liquid, and VERY rarely use stick eyeliner.

Stick eyeliner is sooo much better. it may sound easy but putting on liquid eyeliner is really really hard and it really hurts if it goes in your eye. your much better off using stick as long as you have sharpened it before otherwise the line goes all blotchy

I use both. but I usuallly use liquid.

the problem with liquid is that..one slip..and its in your eyes. you dont really feel it at first..but then..later in the day..you start to feel like 20,000 eyelashes are in your eye. and another thing is that..it takes some time to dry. [[about 30 seconds to 1 minute]]. but I think it is easier to handle eyeliner wise.

but solid eyeliner is harder to remove if you make a mistake. then it gets all smeared and it just doesnt look that good. and it can sometimes get to thick..and it looks bad. I rarely use that anymore.

but I would try both of them out to see what you like. I would recomend the liquid though. but use it a couple of times to see how you like it..=] =]

Solid on the waterline and solid or liquid on the eyelid. Eyeliner on your eyelids can be very difficult to apply though!

I don't use the liquid it kinda looks tacky... well sometimes!!!

I use both. sometimes both at the same time. they are a great substitution cream liner.
liquid first to create the line, and then stick to follow over the line. it makes it look less tacky like the person above me said lol :D