Welcome!


Join more than 152,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Moon landing real or fake ??

fear and loathing Asked by trafficoneman 4 months ago, 25 answers.

What do you think was it faked or was it real ???

I reckon it was faked .

Gir rules. Answered by mikeh on Jul 28, 2009, 10:06AM
1730 answers
Advisor-small

Step by step. Please, for the love of God, pay attention:

1) When the astronauts are putting up the American flag it waves.
It waves due to the motion of the astronaut's hand on the flagpole, not from wind. In fact, it is the lack of air resistance that cause it to wave so dramatically. If the flag were ANYWHERE except total vacuum, the waving would be negligible. Once the hand is removed, the vibrations quickly cease.

2) No blast crater is visible in the pictures taken of the lunar landing module.
That's because no blast crater was created. Lunar gravity is less than 1/4 of Earth's, and so landing on an enormous geyser of flame is not necessary to slow descent. Dust WAS blown back from the module, which is clearly seen on the video, but with no atmosphere on which to drift, most of it fell right back down again.

3) The footprints in the fine lunar dust, with no moisture or atmosphere or strong gravity, are unexpectedly well preserved, as if made in wet sand
There's really no way to counteract this rather strange argument without pictures, which I'm too lazy to post, but countless people have already proven this one to be a little on the bizarre side. Deep dust makes deep footprints, and no gravity and no moisture keeps them crisp. What exactly did you expect?

4) If you speed up the film of the astronauts walking on the Moon’s surface they look like they were filmed on Earth and slowed down.
Mythbusters proved this to be laughably untrue, even going so far as to film a moonwalk in the Vomit Comet. The videos look nothing at all alike.

5) The astronauts could not have survived the trip because of exposure to radiation from the Van Allen radiation belt.
Absolutely true...if they had stayed in space for an entire year. And if they hadn't been in a shielded pod. And if they were naked.

6) The rocks brought back from the Moon are identical to rocks collected by scientific expeditions to Antarctica.
You're probably smart enough to figure this one out for yourself. Moving on...

6) All six Moon landings happened during the Nixon administration. No other national leader has claimed to have landed astronauts on the Moon, despite 40 years of rapid technological development.
What would the reason be? During the Nixon years, it was a commonly held political stance that the only way to stave off nuclear annihilation was to constantly prove one's technological superiority to the enemy, hence the arms race, space race, and so forth. Conquering space was a major milestone, from a military standpoint, and so the frenzied rush to put men on the moon.

Why haven't we gone back in 40 years of rapid technological development? Because -- and listen closely now -- THERE HAVE BEEN 40 YEARS OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT. We have robots that can go there instead. And they are there. Right now. Taking pictures of the moon landing sites:
http://blogs.nature.com/news/thegreatbeyond/369228main_ap14labeled_540.jpg

'Pictures can be Photoshopped!'

Shut the eff up.

3 people thought this was helpful
Me - Created by maggot4 (Raven) Answered by ichibanarky on Jul 28, 2009, 08:29AM
9060 answers
Advisor-small

It was real, but I'd like to hear your opinions on why you think it was fake.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 28, 2009, 08:34AM
397 answers

When the astronauts are putting up the American flag it waves. There is no wind on the Moon.

No blast crater is visible in the pictures taken of the lunar landing module.

The footprints in the fine lunar dust, with no moisture or atmosphere or strong gravity, are unexpectedly well preserved, as if made in wet sand

If you speed up the film of the astronauts walking on the Moon’s surface they look like they were filmed on Earth and slowed down.

The astronauts could not have survived the trip because of exposure to radiation from the Van Allen radiation belt.

The rocks brought back from the Moon are identical to rocks collected by scientific expeditions to Antarctica.

All six Moon landings happened during the Nixon administration. No other national leader has claimed to have landed astronauts on the Moon, despite 40 years of rapid technological development.

And there is more proof aswell

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Jul 28, 2009, 08:36AM
53829 answers

On mythbusters they tested that theroy, it turns out that a flag will wave on hte moon. All the other theroys you said were also tested. They concluded that the moon landing was real.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 28, 2009, 08:38AM
397 answers

Hey cenafan

how ecactly did they test the nixon theory then , or what reason did they give for no more trips to the moon in 40 years .

Me - Created by maggot4 (Raven) Answered by ichibanarky on Jul 28, 2009, 08:55AM
9060 answers
Advisor-small

cenafan is right...all those theories have been tested again and again.

As for your so-important Nixon theory, you stated yourself there was rapid technological development...they've moved on to new things...the moon has been done, why do they need to keep going back?

They've been working on other parts of space.

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 28, 2009, 10:34AM
1775 answers

Good refutation, mikeh. Not to mention, all of this has been thoroughly refuted elsewhere, many, many times. Besides any other questions, why _would_ you go to such an incredible amount of effort - equivalent to really sending astronauts to the moon - to fake it? And how would you keep the thousands of engineers and scientists involved quiet? It all seems pretty pointless to me.

There's several indirect pieces of evidence, if you're prepared to look, too. The lunar landing sites were recently imaged by the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/2009/07/17/apollo-landing-sites-imaged-by-lro/

Also, while on the moon, the Apollo astronauts left behind an experiment called the 'lunar retroreflector'. Anyone with the proper equipment can bounce a laser beam off it, with the beam returning exactly to where you shone it from.

Emma is beautiful Answered by magnus1 on Jul 28, 2009, 07:36PM
53 answers

it was fake.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 12:33AM
397 answers

I still reckon it was fake

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 29, 2009, 12:55AM
1775 answers

***I still reckon it was fake***

_Why_? We've thoroughly debunked all the 'evidence' you presented, and nobody's even presented a plausible reason why anyone would want to fake the moon landings in the first place. Is the idea that man landed on the moon so mind blowing that you can't accept it?

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 02:35AM
397 answers

no ye have not mythbusters have and even though I love that show I dont take their findings as gospel , I have no problem with ye beliving it was real I just dont agree ,
And the fact that man landed on the moon id not mind blowing to me atall , whats mindblowing to me it that they are ment to have done it with 1960 technology .

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 29, 2009, 03:35AM
1775 answers

You still haven't explained _why_ you think it's fake despite having all your 'evidence' debunked - or why you think it's not debunked, for that matter.

What specific bit of 1960s technology do you doubt was capable of doing what it was claimed to do?

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 04:18AM
397 answers

I dont belive the theorys have been debunked , I think we will just have to dissagree , why are you so threatened by someone who differs in opinion , why cant you seem to accept I dont belive , we cand differ on opinion its ok

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 29, 2009, 05:40AM
1775 answers

I'm not threatened by you, I'm puzzled. You persist in believing in something absurd despite ample evidence against it and no evidence for it, but refuse to state why it is that you continue to believe in it.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 06:00AM
397 answers

I stated why already , and also I dont trust goverment , you prob think JFK was realy shot by lee havey oswald aswell dont ya.

Gir rules. Answered by mikeh on Jul 29, 2009, 06:35AM
1730 answers
Advisor-small

Oh, Lee Havey. He was a scamp.

So let's get this straight -- you don't trust your government to be able to put men on the moon, but you DO trust them to be able to coordinate a massive multinational conspiracy involving thousands of people and the spending of hundreds of BILLIONS of dollars, not to mention the silencing of thousands of private citizens and the subversion of countless pieces of physical evidence without a single person blowing the whistle?

It seems like in order to not trust your government, you've placed more trust in it than any single person has ever trusted anything, ever. So yes, you are perfectly entitled to your opinion, but if you air it publicly, we are also entitled to call your opinion bats**t insane.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 07:06AM
397 answers

Why you belive that he shot JFK seriously.

and for the the record im irish , it aint my goverment , if we are talking about my goverment I dont even trust Mr Cowen to wipe his own a55

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 29, 2009, 07:14AM
1775 answers

***and for the the record im irish , it aint my goverment***

That's not the point - under the guise of not trusting the (US) government, you're claiming they have an unreal, nigh impossible level of competence when it comes to creating multi-billion-dollar conspiracies involving thousands of people without a single piece of evidence or a single person talking.

fear and loathing Answered by trafficoneman on Jul 29, 2009, 07:22AM
397 answers

So you belive it too my god , do ye belive everything ye are told , its fact that jfk's head went the oppisit way to the way it should of went if he was shot by oswald thats just phisics , but belive what ye want its been nice debating with ye but we are gettin nowere and I got work to do laters .

Me when I'm busy Answered by arachnid on Jul 29, 2009, 07:41AM
1775 answers

***its fact that jfk's head went the oppisit way to the way it should of went if he was shot by oswald ***

Funnily enough, Mythbusters has demonstrated why that's nonsense too. But you're avoiding the question - we weren't talking about JFK, we were talking about the moon landings and why you think the US government is simultaneously too incompetent to send men to the moon, and so hyper-competent that they can arrange a conspiracy involving thousands of people with no leakage.

Gir rules. Answered by mikeh on Jul 29, 2009, 10:01AM
1730 answers
Advisor-small

Right, I wasn't giving credence to your mentioning of yet another conspiracy theory on top of your first, I was just pointing out that you misspelled Harvey.

With regards to JFK's head-snapping physics, keep in mind that your understanding of physics also led you to believe that a flag shouldn't wave on the moon or that a footprint won't remain in a vacuum.

1 person thought this was helpful

Answer this Question: "Moon landing real or fake ??"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Our members said the answers on this page also answer the following questions:


Moonlanding-real or fake?, Moon landing fake flag waving?, Jfk fake moon landing?, 1960s man on the moon a fake??, Moon blast fake?, Incredible fake photos moon landing?, Geyser trips earth leakage?, Moon landing real?, "moon landing"! "fake" real?, Was the moon landing real funadvice?, Was the space landing real -hoax?, Mirish debunk crater?, Why no more moon landings?, Flag on moon why is real and not fake?, Fake lunar landing pictures?, Moisture moon during landing

Science Photos

twilight new moonthe moonNew Moon

Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
Moon landing real or fake ??