Guys: skinny girls or heavier girls?

Guys: Do think a girl is more attractive with some extra pounds on her, or to be skinny?

Me personally, I like a few curves, rather than stick thin. But physical attributes matter less than personality. Society (mostly western, but not exclusively) seems to be putting the message that skinny is the only way to look hot or beautiful. That's crap.

I like a girl who is skinny personally. Not like..ribs showing skinny, but healthy/athletic. There are limits to how skinny/overweight you can be, and these limits differ from guy to guy. Be happy with how you are and never feel ugly or different in a bad way.
Chris XX

As a girl who is attracted to both genders, I think I can ignore the "guys" criteria here.

I can't say I find one more appealing than the other. It can depend on a number of variables. I'd rather have a girl/guy who doesn't count calories than someone who does. Danbob's right in the fact that personality counts big time. If it came down to choosing between the supermodel with a 10 year old's viewpoint on life matters, or the average looking person with a good sense of humour and some intelligent insight on life matters, I'd go for the average person.

But weight wise, I find lots of different women attractive: Liv Tyler, Nikki Blonsky, Rose McGowan, Sara Rue to name a few celebrities. Size isn't really a big issue.

me personally, I like skinnier girls

I don't really care about what a girl looks like as long as they aren't unhealthy. OVERweight girls and anorexic girls, I don't like their looks and just feel sorry for them.

I prefer sturdy girls, not anemic ones...

I prefer girls that have a few extra pounds. not a lot.
just not really skinny, and just not huge .
I would not go for a girl that is either anorexic or overweight.

Men I love girls that have, you know flesh in all the 'right places'. A girl with lovely curves does it for me but she must have a lovely personality though.