Welcome!


Join more than 151,000 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

What is the difference between atheism and agnosticism?

Evening Sky Asked by airnavigator over 2 years ago, 9 answers.

What is the difference between Atheism and Agnosticism?

Question closed
mamakat Answered by mamakat on Oct 03, 2007, 08:26AM
54 answers

I think its that Atheists believe, without a doubt, that there is no God and Agnostics aren't really sure and don't care much anyways.

1 person thought this was helpful
Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Oct 03, 2007, 08:34AM
53985 answers

One is not a valid non-religion.

Atheists are people who don't believe in God who (usually) base their lack of belief on scientific facts and evidence. Agnostics are people who are not knowledgeable about the existence of God. Agnosticism usually goes hand-in-hand with atheism, whereas gnosticism goes hand-in-hand with theism.

Whiteboard portrate Answered by filletofspam on Oct 03, 2007, 08:45AM
2970 answers
Advisor-small

No, but the answer depends on if you want a one line definition or to fully understand the various viewpoints.

The a- and an- suffix mean not as in asexual (reproduces without sex) anhydrous (no water) etc. By this an atheist is someone who is not a theist. Generally atheists accept the possibility of god(s) but find it highly unlikely; I fall into that camp. Among atheists some make the distinction of strong and weak atheists. A weak atheist doesn't believe in god(s) while a strong atheist believes there is no god. Weak indicating lack of belief in god and the strong indicating a belief that there are no gods.

Agnosticism is a term coined by Thomas Huxley. Huxley noted that many people felt like they solved the mystery of the universe with the god explination or with a purely physical materialistic explination. He felt that ultimate truths are unknowable (such as the existance of God). Of course the inconsistancy is that if the ultimate truths are unknowable that this is an ultimate truth; therefore an agnostic can not believe in agnosticism. FWIW, I am also an agnostic. I believe that the ultimate truths are unknowable; we just do the best we can and go from there.

Popularly agnostic is used to describe someone who isn't sure of the existance of God and atheist is someone who denies the existance of god.

Whiteboard portrate Answered by filletofspam on Oct 03, 2007, 09:08AM
2970 answers
Advisor-small

Actually gnosticism is a religious viewpoint that followers are saved by having certain knowledge that only they are privy to. There were Gnostic Christians and their beliefs were quite interesting. When Constatine made Christianity the official religion of the Roman Empire any Christian groups deemed heretical were wiped out, Gnostics being one of these groups.

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Oct 03, 2007, 09:28AM
53985 answers

Atheist base their belief on Scientific theory which changes every 5 - 80 years and Agnostics base their beliefs on lack of knowledge. go ahead look it up.

Whiteboard portrate Answered by filletofspam on Oct 03, 2007, 11:37AM
2970 answers
Advisor-small

There were atheists long before the theory of evolution, before we knew the age of the world, and before we had good theories on the origin of the cosmos.

I've never met an atheist who quit believing in God because evolution or the Bib Bang theory made such sense to them. They quit believing based on a perceived weakness of religion rather than the strength of scientific explinations. The most common viewpoint among believers is dualism. They do not see science and religion as opposed to each other; they see them as answers to different questions. Only fundamentalists generally see their worldview challenged by scientific investigation.

Most atheists don't think they have all the answers, we are fine admitting that there are things we don't know. The fact that we don't understand things (like how life sprung from lifelessness, how the cosmos formed, etc) doesn't cause us to latch onto supernatural explinations though.

If it was proven that the cosmos didn't start with a big bang or that evolution doesn't work the way we thought it did it wouldn't cause me to turn to religion.

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Oct 03, 2007, 12:44PM
53985 answers

Actually gnosticism is a religious viewpoint that followers are saved by having certain knowledge that only they are privy to.

That would be Gnosticism with a capital G. Gnosticism with a lowercase G simply means knowing. Most atheists would say that they're not 100% sure that God doesn't exist (Even the Great Richard Dawkins is only 99.9% sure), but most atheists would say that they're 100% sure that God exists.

Pfft, I'm always right.

I don't think Gnostics believed in being saved at all because they didn't believe in the Biblical God. They seemed to be more interested in knowing the ultimate truth, not going to heaven. I've read that some Gnostics believed the Biblical God was almost like a devil-like hindrance to us all. That was a very interesting idea.

Shark Atack Answered by funadvice on Oct 03, 2007, 09:38PM
53985 answers

From a neutral standpoint: Atheists believe there is no God. Agnostics believe the existence of God can be neither proven nor disproven.

From my standpoint: Agnostics believe that Theists AND Atheists are BOTH WRONG.

Oh, and the definition of 'Agnostic' that mentioned a 'lack of knowledge' ...it meant GLOBALLY, not personally.

Comment for armenia_guy's profile Answered by summerrainn on Aug 03, 2008, 07:23PM
94 answers

Both are missing spirituality in their lives, they are generally very pathetic.

Ask a question related to: "What is the difference between Atheism and Agnosticism?"

Title: Give your question a title

Ask your Question: HTML is not allowed.

Category: Choose a category



Religion & Spirituality Photos

This is a different cat whose healthierThis is me, I like to be different ;)harold kalele

Religion & Spirituality Questions

Your reaction to agnosticism/atheism is...?


Share this question

Copy and paste this code:
It will display on your blog or site like this:
What is the difference between atheism and agnosticism?