Carly and her mom

Carly and her mom were having dinner. carly got up to get a glass of water. she was standing at the kitchen sink standing side ways.

Mom: “carly did you lose weight”
Carly: “no. but mom you are always telling me that I look beautiful”
Mom: “you do look beautiful but your pants look bigger. you know you are skinny enough”

Carly called me and told me what her mom said
Carly: “is my mother implying I wasn’t always skinny”
Lover454: “no she never said that, she even tells you that you are skinny. all she wanted to know is if you lost weight because your pants looked bigger”

My question: do you agree with me?

Keep in mind that last week when carly and her mom went to visit carly’s aunt in another state they took the bus. (carlys aunt gave a description of carly to the cab driver who was going to pick up carly and her mom up at the bus depot sayng carly is very skinny. (and the last time the aunt saw carly was a year ago.)

Yes, 'Carly' is very offensive and thinks her mother is implying she wasn't skinny, when she's very skinny.

Tell Carly she needs a counselor for her eating disorder.

this question seems very similar to your last one about 'Patricia'. I think that 'Carly' and 'Patricia' need to get some help from a doctor or someone who cares about them because these stories are implying that they aren't healthy and that their families and even strangers are noticing.